EUROPE POLITICS
Putin’s invasion of Ukraine is seen as his biggest ever mistake — and it will harm Russia for years to come
PUBLISHED THU, MAR 24 2022 4:25 AM EDT ... UPDATED THU, MAR 24 2022 9:32 AM EDT
Holly Ellyatt @HOLLYELLYATT
KEY POINTS
- Russian President Vladimir Putin has been in power for more than two decades and during that time has carefully cultivated an image of himself as a tough, strongman leader.
- Now, analysts say his decision to invade Ukraine is the biggest mistake of his political career and has weakened Russia for years to come.
- Russia’s position, both economically and geopolitically, looks increasingly isolated and vulnerable.
Russian President Vladimir Putin attends a concert marking the eighth anniversary of Russia's annexation of Crimea from Ukraine at the Luzhniki stadium in Moscow on March 18, 2022.
Russian President Vladimir Putin attends a concert marking the eighth anniversary of Russia’s annexation of Crimea from Ukraine at the Luzhniki stadium in Moscow on March 18, 2022.
Mikhail Klimentyev | Afp | Getty Images
Russian President Vladimir Putin has been in power for more than two decades and during that time has carefully cultivated an image of himself as a tough, strongman leader, fighting for Russia’s interests and reinstating the country as a geopolitical and economic superpower.
With his decision to invade neighboring Ukraine, however, analysts say Putin has made the biggest mistake of his political career and has weakened Russia for years to come.
“Everything he has done up to this point [conferred] reputational damage to Russia, but it also enhanced power. And he just kept going and kept going and kept going,” Kurt Volker, former U.S. ambassador to NATO, told CNBC.
“But now he has actually dramatically weakened Russia, in every respect,” he said, adding that he could not think of anything that Putin has done in his political career that’s comparable.
Global leaders are gathering in Europe on Thursday to discuss the war in Ukraine and how to help the country survive Russia’s onslaught: An extraordinary NATO summit in Brussels, as well as meetings of EU leaders and the G-7.
NATO is expected to commit to “major increases” in troop numbers along its eastern flank as well as more arms and humanitarian assistance for Ukraine, although the military alliance has been reluctant to go further, fearing a direct confrontation with nuclear power Russia.
NATO: President Putin has made a big mistake
Speaking to CNBC on Thursday, NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg said, “President Putin has made a big mistake and that is to launch a war, to wage a war, against an independent sovereign nation.”
“He has underestimated the strength of the Ukrainian people, the bravery of the Ukrainian people and armed forces,” Stoltenberg told CNBC’s Hadley Gamble.
NATO’s plans to step up support for Ukraine, and deployments in Eastern Europe would allow it to respond to “any threat, any challenge, to our security.”
War crimes
Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has, in one month, prompted more than 3.5 million civilians to flee the country, with hundreds of thousands losing their homes in a relentless bombardment by Russian forces.
The southern city of Mariupol has been the worst hit so far, with the port — a key export hub for Ukraine — still under siege and heavily destroyed.
Ukraine’s president, Volodymyr Zelenskyy, has said there are around 100,000 civilians still trapped in the city, where water, food, electricity and medical supplies are scarce.
This image made available by Azov Battalion, shows the drama theater, damaged after shelling, in Mariupol, Ukraine, Thursday March 17, 2022.
This image made available by Azov Battalion, shows the drama theater, damaged after shelling, in Mariupol, Ukraine, Thursday March 17, 2022.
Azov Battalion | AP
Despite deploying near-constant shelling attacks and siege tactics in some areas, Russian forces have only captured one city — Kherson — and a much-feared assault on the capital Kyiv has yet to begin. In addition, the country’s second-largest city, Kharkiv, continues to resist Russian attacks and the western city of Lviv is currently relatively unscathed.
The U.K. Defense Ministry said Wednesday that little had been gained by Russian forces, despite attempts to envelop Ukrainian troops in the east of the country.
Read more
How will Russia’s war with Ukraine end? Here are 5 possible outcomes
It’s becoming clear to both Moscow and Kyiv that this war will not be easily won — and in the meantime, Putin has made Russia a pariah on the international stage.
Secretary of State Antony Blinken announced Wednesday that the U.S government believes Russia has committed war crimes in Ukraine and should be prosecuted.
Putin’s best option ‘by far’ is a diplomatic settlement, says professor
In a statement, Blinken compared the destruction in Mariupol to similar Russian campaigns against Grozny in the Second Chechen War and Aleppo during the Syrian civil war.
“Russia’s forces have destroyed apartment buildings, schools, hospitals, critical infrastructure, civilian vehicles, shopping centers, and ambulances, leaving thousands of innocent civilians killed or wounded,” he said.
Russia has repeatedly said it does not target civilian infrastructure, despite much evidence to the contrary. CNBC has contacted the Kremlin for a response to the U.S. accusation that Russia has committed war crimes and is awaiting a reply.
Growth wiped out
Under Putin’s leadership — and until now — Russia’s economy has prospered.
Putin attracted much foreign direct investment to the country and exploited its natural resources, particularly its abundance of oil and gas, as well as trying to diversify the economy.
During his tenure, however, Russia has also been hit by economic misfortunes both of its own making — such as international sanctions after its 2014 annexation of Crimea from Ukraine, a nerve agent attack in the U.K. and its meddling in the 2016 U.S. election — and some it had no control over, such as the 2008 financial crisis, 2014 oil price crash and most recently, the Covid-19 pandemic.
Read more
5 charts show Russia’s economic highs and lows under Putin
Now, Russia’s economic misfortunes are once again ones that Putin has brought upon the country himself with the invasion of Ukraine.
The economy is already creaking under the weight of international sanctions and on Thursday, when U.S. President Joe Biden meets with European and NATO leaders in Brussels, even more sanctions could be imposed squeezing energy exporter Russia hard.
CRIMEA, RUSSIA - FEBRUARY 24, 2022: A column of army trucks moves across the town of Armyansk, northern Crimea. Early on February 24, President Putin announced a special military operation to be conducted by the Russian Armed Forces in response to appeals
A column of army trucks moves across the town of Armyansk, northern Crimea. Early on February 24, President Putin announced a special military operation to be conducted by the Russian Armed Forces in response to appeals for help from the leaders of the Donetsk and Lugansk People’s Republics.
Sergei Malgavko | TASS | Getty Images
The Institute of International Finance has said it expects Russia’s economy to contract by 15% in 2022, driven by both official sanctions and the “self-sanctioning” of foreign companies that have pulled out of Russia.
Predicting a further economic decline of 3% in 2023, the IIF said Wednesday that the war “will wipe out fifteen years of economic growth.” Moreover, it said the impact on medium- and long-term prospects is likely to be even more severe, with a “brain drain” and low investment likely to weigh heavily.
Putin unrepentant
Despite making limited progress in his invasion so far, Putin appears undeterred.
Russian forces are now believed to be conducting a period of reorganization before resuming large-scale offensive operations on and around Kyiv.
WATCH NOW
VIDEO02:53
Russia’s Putin, oligarchs do not care about sanctions, says former NATO ambassador
Taras Kuzio, a research fellow at the Henry Jackson Society, wrote in an article for the Atlantic Council on Tuesday that it is “increasingly obvious that Russian President Vladimir Putin has badly miscalculated.”
’He appears to have sincerely believed Kremlin propaganda fairytales about the weakness of the Ukrainian military and the readiness of ordinary Ukrainians to welcome his invading troops with cakes and flowers,” Kuzio said, stating that Putin had drunk the Kremlin “kool-aid.”
In addition, Putin seems to have been unprepared for the ferocity of the international response or for the scale of domestic opposition to his invasion, Kuzio noted. “Thanks to these catastrophic miscalculations, Putin now finds himself with no good options to end a war that is threatening to accelerate Russia’s geopolitical decline as a great power.”
Read more
Putin’s obsession with Ukraine has made analysts question his rationality
Putin's obsession with Ukraine has made analysts question his rationality
Russia has few friends left on the global stage, with the invasion almost universally condemned. Even Russia’s ally China appears uneasy about the potentially prolonged conflict in Ukraine and its impact on the global economy.
When the U.N. General Assembly met in early March, 141 countries adopted a resolution demanding that Russia immediately end its military operations in Ukraine. Only a handful of countries — a rogue’s gallery of Belarus, North Korea, Eritrea and Syria, all of which are run by dictators — supported Russia’s invasion. Russia’s allies Cuba, Nicaragua and China abstained in the vote.
Is Russia over?
Close watchers of Putin say there are increasing signs of desperation in Russia’s military campaign and have questioned how far Putin will go to achieve his objectives.
“There are deep mysteries about Russian intentions,” Ian Lesser, vice president of the German Marshall Fund of the U.S., told CNBC earlier this month. “How far will they go? What would they consider a victory?”
“There are all sorts of possibilities, from a complete occupation of Ukraine, which I think most observers would say is not possible, to control over a couple of critical political centres in Ukraine, including Kyiv and possibly including Odesa, or perhaps they take have a larger territorial gambit in mind.”
In such a scenario, he said Russia would be “very exposed” to an ongoing insurgency which also implies ongoing humanitarian costs. “So there are large dilemmas here,” Lesser added.
WATCH NOW
VIDEO07:16
Putin is desperate — and could resort to using chemical weapons: German Marshall Fund director
Michal Baranowski, senior fellow and director of the German Marshall Fund’s Warsaw office, told CNBC on Tuesday, that Putin has “really overextended himself.”
“We might be looking at the end of Russia as we have known it,” he said. “But if he survives this, I think what we might be looking at is the foothills of a new Cold War.”
CNBC Politics
Read more of CNBC’s politics coverage:
Rocket attack on Ukraine train station kills at least 50 trying to flee, scores injured
‘We’ve made it’: Emotional Ketanji Brown Jackson, first Black woman to join Supreme Court, touts confirmation as a mark of progress
New York City loses court fight to boot Trump Organization from operating Bronx golf course
Beverly Hills Castle & the Technicolored Rolls Royce
WATCH LIVElogo
UP NEXT | AMA Supercross 07:30 pm ET
logo
TV
Beverly Hills Castle & the Technicolored Rolls Royce
WATCH LIVElogo
UP NEXT | AMA Supercross 07:30 pm ET
Listen
TRENDING NOW
Elon Musk and Grimes attend the Heavenly Bodies: Fashion & The Catholic Imagination Costume Institute Gala at The Metropolitan Museum of Art
Elon Musk says humans could eventually download their brains into robots
Graham Cochrane, Founder of The Recording Revolution, started his business in 2009 during The Great Recession.
This 38-year-old makes $160,000 per month in passive income: ‘I work only 5 hours a week now’
A Harvard nutritionist shares the No. 1 food she eats every day to keep her brain ‘sharp and focused’
17-year-old Bryson Warren, a member of the Overtime Elite basketball league.
This 17-year-old is getting paid at least $100,000 to play high school basketball
Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and British Prime Minister Boris Johnson walk at the Independence Square after a meeting, as Russia's attack on Ukraine continues, in Kyiv, Ukraine April 9, 2022.
Boris Johnson vows more military aid to Ukraine, warns Putin will intensify pressure in the east
by TaboolaSponsored LinksFROM THE WEB
Top analyst warns: “You’re about to miss the market turn”
Investing Outlook
“Move your money by early 2022,” Wall street legend warns
Chaikin Analytics
Sponsored
MORE FROM CNBC
- Photos show world’s largest cargo plane destroyed in Ukraine
- Hungary’s nationalist leader Orban criticizes Ukraine’s Zelenskyy in election victory speech
- France finally looks set to raise its retirement age. And the war in Ukraine might have helped
U.S. authorities accuse Russian oligarch Viktor Vekselberg of bank fraud, money laundering as his yacht is seized
Man accused of impersonating DHS agent offered one of Jill Biden's Secret Service agents an assault rifle, court records s…
Empty canals, dead cotton fields: Arizona farmers are getting slammed by water cuts in the West
FROM THE WEB
Top analyst warns: “You’re about to miss the market turn”
Investing Outlook
“Move your money by early 2022,” Wall street legend warns
Chaikin Analytics
The Unusual Is Usual in Louisiana
Louisiana Tourism
by Taboola
MORE IN EUROPE POLITICS
NATO to expand? Chief says Finland — which borders Russia — would be warmly welcomed to the alliance
Sam Meredith
EU’s new Russia sanctions to likely include steel, luxury goods, jet fuel and more, sources say
Silvia Amaro
French markets skittish as far-right candidate Le Pen closes gap in election polls
Elliot Smith
Why a Russia-Ukraine deal will be difficult to reach
Abigail Ng
EU proposes ban on Russian coal, working on oil sanctions
Silvia Amaro
by Taboola
FROM THE WEB
Amazon Has Millions of Prime Subscribers — But Few Know About This Savings Trick
Sponsored
:
Capital One Shopping
Put $25 Here Before Coinbase Makes Their Next Move
Sponsored
:
The Legacy Report
Sponsored
Millions Of Ukrainians Need Food Assistance
Severe Shortages Of Food And Drinking Water. Empty Grocery Shelves. Ukrainians Need Help.
Sponsored
:
UN World Food Program USA
The Future Of Hybrid & Electric SUVs Is Here, See 2022′s Top Models
Sponsored
:
2022 SUV Guide | Search Ads
Motley Fool Advisors on Post-Retirement Income
Our advisors share their approach to keeping income steady in retirement. Download the free guide + learn more about 6 post-retirement income streams.
Sponsored
:
Motley Fool Wealth Management
by Taboola
FROM THE WEB
New Volkswagen’s Finally On Sale
Sponsored
:
All Things Auto
Got $1,000 To Invest? Here’s Our Idea
Sponsored
:
The Motley Fool
This Is Where Educated Singles Meet in Pennsylvania
Sponsored
:
EliteSingles
Salary vs. owner’s draw: How to pay yourself as a business owner
Sponsored
:
QuickBooks
New Anti-Mosquito Device Is Taking the US by Storm
Sponsored
:
Moskito Pro
MORE FROM CNBC
Op-ed: A new world order is emerging — and the world is not ready for it
Frederick Kempe
War crime charges won’t be enough to deter Putin — even as evidence of Russian atrocities mounts
Karen Gilchrist
Map of nuclear power in the US: See where reactors are located
Catherine Clifford
Nearly 70% of Americans are worried about a nuclear attack, according to APA survey. Here’s what could happen
Charlotte Morabito
Congress votes to revoke Russia’s ‘most favored nation’ trade status, sends bill to Biden
Thomas Franck
by Taboola
FROM THE WEB
Claiming the Home Office Tax Deduction
Sponsored
:
TurboTax
The Men’s Shoes for Standing All Day Without Discomfort - Now 70% Off
Sponsored
:
Antoniglobal
Amazon Has Millions Of Prime Subscribers - but Few Know About This Savings Trick
Sponsored
:
OnlineShoppingTools.com
Which Ceramic Sealants Were Voted Best for 2022?
Sponsored
:
Torque Detail
Self-Employed? Don’t Overlook Any Of These Tax Write-Offs
Sponsored
:
TurboTax
by Taboola
FROM THE WEB
Last-Minute First-Class Flight Deals
Sometimes waiting till the last-minute works best. Get last-minute deals on first-class and business-class seats when using these top sites…
Sponsored
:
Discount Flights | Search Ads
“One Stock Is All You Need” Says Trader Jeff Clark
Sponsored
:
Jeff Clark Trader
Expert Unveils “No. 1 Gold Play For 2022”
Learn More
Sponsored
:
Stansberry Research
Most American Chrome Users Didn’t Know This (Do It Now)
Most Chrome Users Don’t Know This. Run a Free Security Scan Now
Sponsored
:
guard.io
Avoid Paying Full Price — This Tool Can Find You Amazon Coupons Instantly
Sponsored
:
Capital One Shopping
MORE FROM CNBC
Inside the $87 million hilltop palace for sale in Beverly Hills
Ray Parisi
This daughter and father founded a company to bury nuclear waste by drilling deep boreholes
Catherine Clifford
Elon Musk says Tesla may have to get into the lithium business because costs are so ‘insane’
Catherine Clifford
Yellen warns that war in Ukraine will have ‘enormous’ global economic impact
Jeff Cox
Demand for used cars drops from a year ago but high prices aren’t budging
Sarah O’Brien
by Taboola
FROM THE WEB
Pennsylvania Launches New Guidelines For Cars Used Less Than 50 Miles/Day
Sponsored
:
BindRight Auto Insurance Quotes
“ I know these shoes will last for years.” - Tom - Now 70% Off!
Sponsored
:
horuste
New “Smart” Security Camera Thieves Hate (It’s Genius!)
Shop now and get 50% off - Today Only!
Sponsored
:
Smartbulb360
Business Class Flight Deals
Get great deals on low cost business class flights to anywhere in the world. Right now is a great time to fulfill your travel needs.
Sponsored
:
Business Flights | Search Ads
VW’s New EV Lineup Will Leave You Breathless
Sponsored
:
New VWs | search ads
by Taboola
FROM THE WEB
Hands Down The Top Credit Card of 2022
This top cash back card offers a super easy $200 sign-up bonus and unlimited 2% cash back on purchases, all with no annual fee.
Sponsored
:
CompareCredit.com
A spray paint that sticks to nearly anything.
Tackle indoor and outdoor restoration projects with confidence because you’ve got 5X Stronger Adhesion*.
Sponsored
:
Krylon® Fusion All-In-One®
Nissan Has Done It Again. This Year’s Lineup Has Left Us Speechless
Sponsored
:
All Things Auto | Search Ads
The Best Electric Cars of 2022 and 2023
Sponsored
:
Edmunds
The Price of Private Jet Rental in 2022 Might Surprise You
Sponsored
:
Trending
MORE FROM CNBC
Putin is preparing an eastern offensive in Ukraine. Here’s how this phase of the war could unfold
Sam Meredith
Russia debt default prospect resurfaces as U.S. blocks bond payment
Elliot Smith
U.S. sanctions Putin’s adult children, bans all new investment in Russia
Christina Wilkie
Biden calls to put Putin on trial for war crimes over Russia killings in Ukraine
Dan Mangan
Ukraine war is a key test in how the world responds to abuse of power, ex-UK foreign minister says
Tania Bryer
| The text being discussed is available at
and
| |
