Date: 2024-12-30 Page is: DBtxt003.php txt00013725
INDUSTRIAL SAFETY
TOXIC CHEMICALS IN THE HOUSTON AREA
Part 1 of series by investigative journalists from the Houston Chronicle
TOXIC CHEMICALS IN THE HOUSTON AREA
Part 1 of series by investigative journalists from the Houston Chronicle
Chemical companies, including Goodyear, sit across from a park near Pasadena. Goodyear ranked near the top of plants that pose a high potential for harm, according to a yearlong Houston Chronicle/A&M investigation. (Michael Ciaglo / Houston Chronicle)
Original article: http://www.houstonchronicle.com/chemical-breakdown/1/
Burgess COMMENTARY
Peter Burgess
A Houston Chronicle/Texas A&M analysis looks at the potential for harm from 2,500 facilities in Greater Houston.
Story by Mark Collette and Matt Dempsey
First in a series
Just outside Pearland, theater patrons come and go within 200 feet of a warehouse that stockpiles a pesticide so toxic it seeped into a family’s house in Utah and killed two little girls.
A metal forging company about a half-mile from Cy-Fair High School stores 27 chemicals, including titanium, a material that blew up at a golf club manufacturer in Los Angeles and leveled a city block.
And in Crosby, a public sports complex is close to a plant that houses explosive organic peroxides, a class of chemicals used in terror attacks in Paris and Brussels.
All over America and across greater Houston, capital of the nation’s petrochemical industry, hundreds of chemicals pose serious threats to public safety at facilities that may be unknown to most neighbors and are largely unpoliced by government at all levels, a yearlong Houston Chronicle investigation reveals.
The Occupational Safety and Health Administration doesn’t inspect most facilities; when it does, it’s often due to an accident or complaint. The Environmental Protection Agency ignores entire classes of hazardous chemicals when looking at which sites to scrutinize. Texas and other states have made accessing information about chemical stockpiles more difficult. Local emergency planning groups are in many cases unfunded and, in the most extreme instances, staff lists include people who have died.
The danger is real. Since November 2014, when four employees died after a gas leak at a DuPont plant in La Porte, there have been 12 explosions, fires and toxic releases widely reported around greater Houston, including one on Thursday that destroyed a Spring Branch packing facility that handles hazardous materials. That’s one every six weeks. Nationally, at least 17 people have died and 573 have been hospitalized in more than 93 incidents involving hazardous chemicals in the last year and a half.
In response to the DuPont accident, the Chronicle obtained the chemical inventories of more than 2,500 businesses in greater Houston. Chemical safety experts at Texas A&M University’s Mary Kay O’Connor Process Safety Center then ranked the potential of each facility to kill or injure people and cause property or environmental damage should an incident occur. The analysis was based on the properties and quantities of the chemicals and the size of the surrounding population.
The results – adjusted for OSHA violations and company responses – found 55 facilities with the highest potential for harm to the public. Close to 600 scored in the medium tier, storing chemicals dangerous enough to impose serious harm in an accident. Nearly 80 percent of the facilities in those tiers have 10,000 or more people within a 2-mile radius.
One medium-tier plant: The DuPont facility in La Porte, where the 2014 leak involved methyl mercaptan, a highly flammable chemical that never found a spark. If it had, the explosion could have hurled debris, piercing tanks of hydrogen fluoride. That could kill and injure people up to 25 miles away, encompassing an area with more than 2 million residents, according to information DuPont and its spinoff company, Chemours, disclosed to the EPA. Such an accident nearly happened at an ExxonMobil plant in California, where flying debris narrowly missed a hydrogen fluoride tank, the U.S. Chemical Safety Board reported.
Sam Mannan, who heads the O’Connor center and is one of the nation’s preeminent experts on chemical safety, watches the same root causes play out again and again in accidents – lack of assessed risks, communities kept in the dark, inattention to zoning. “We are literally running from disaster to disaster without a well thought-out plan,” he said.
It’s only a matter of time, Mannan said, before an accident reaches beyond a plant’s fenceline to claim lives.
A&M Report Editor’s note:
In response to the DuPont accident in November 2014, the Houston Chronicle obtained the chemical inventories of more than 2,500 businesses in Greater Houston. Chemical safety experts at Texas A&M University’s Mary Kay O’Connor Process Safety Center then ranked the potential for harm from each facility should an incident occur.
There are differences between the original Texas A&M report, published in January 2016, and the data used by the Chronicle in the Chemical Breakdown series.
The A&M report included facilities outside our metro area, because some companies in Harrison County mistakenly provided their chemical inventories to Houston-area Local Emergency Planning Committees. The Chronicle removed those facilities from its list.
A&M researchers wanted to factor in each facility's accident history, but comprehensive accident histories don't exist. So researchers endorsed the use of regulatory histories by the Chronicle and recommended that facilities with OSHA process safety violations receive a one-point penalty. Six facilities moved from the mid-tier to the highest category due to inspection histories.
Three companies moved down to the mid-tier after giving the Chronicle updated information on chemicals and A&M recalculated scores.
The Chronicle received AkzoNobel Surface Chemistry's Tier Two in 2016, after the publication of the report. A&M evaluated its inventory using the study methodology, and the plant landed on the high potential for harm list.
=====================================================
=====================================================
DOCUMENT Zoom
« Page 1 of 43 »
The Texas A&M analysis
Degesch America’s pesticide warehouse is surrounded by a chain-link fence north of Pearland. The Pearl Theater is across the street. The only signs of potential danger at Degesch are two diamond placards near the front door, marked with colors and numbers that, to first-responders, offer important warnings: reacts with water, highly flammable, fatal if inhaled.
The aluminum phosphide inside is so toxic it can’t legally be used within 100 feet of a building that could be occupied by living creatures.
Degesch ranked second for potential harm in the A&M analysis, partly because of the pesticide’s toxicity and also because it can house up to 75,000 pounds. It took less than 2 pounds of aluminum phosphide pellets placed in the ground around a home in Utah to produce enough gas to slowly kill a 4-year-old and her baby sister in 2010.
“There’s 1,200 chemical pesticides out there, and I’d put this one at the top of the list of things that scare me,” said Dave Stone, an environmental toxicologist and former director of the National Pesticide Information Center at Oregon State University.
The A&M analysis does not measure the risk of an accident happening, where a problem is likely to occur or the safety of the operations at a given facility.
Mannan noted that the properties that make chemicals dangerous also make them inherently useful. He hopes the analysis will inspire industry and government to better manage the risks.
Facilities across the country would likely produce similar results, in terms of the percentages in each tier, if the same methodology was applied, Mannan said.
Federal law requires companies to file inventories that include any of more than 500,000 hazardous products. Based on the data collected from greater Houston companies, A&M evaluated 983 substances. But under the EPA’s Risk Management Program, its chief accident prevention strategy, the agency looks at only 148 chemicals, ignoring places like Degesch.
The A&M study does not cover all of greater Houston.
Many facilities that produce or house hazardous chemicals couldn’t be identified by the Chronicle because the state allowed local governments to withhold inventories, citing a Texas law that restricts information that might be useful to terrorists. Brazoria and Galveston counties, home to some of the largest concentrations of chemical plants in the world, refused the paper’s request. So did Fort Bend and Waller counties.
A federal right-to-know law mandates disclosure, under the theory that the public is better protected by being informed. The law is not enforced.
Degesch rejected interview requests from the Chronicle – two employees hung up on reporters – and an inquiry to the company’s German headquarters went unanswered.
Peter van Nifterik, president of the Pearl Theater, knew nothing about the pesticide stored at Degesch. He assumed the facility was as benign as the plumbing place next door.
If an incident happened at Degesch during a show, Van Nifterik said he wouldn’t know whether to take shelter or evacuate.
Pearland neighbors
Degesch is in a light industrial park, with warehouses, crane suppliers and machine shops, and is about three quarters of a mile from Shadow Creek Ranch.
The suburban community of up to 12,000 homes with sought-after schools is the kind of place where people live precisely because it’s nowhere near the Houston industrial complex.
But other sites of concern are on either side of the industrial park. AkzoNobel Surface Chemistry operates a 45-acre plant southwest of Degesch that, among dozens of other hazardous materials, stores up to 2 million pounds of ethylene oxide, a highly flammable, explosive and toxic gas.
The plant has tanks and a couple of towers, but it doesn’t look like its massive counterparts on Houston’s east side. People with extensive experience in Pearland real estate – two salespeople for home builders and one agent – said prospective buyers almost never ask about AkzoNobel, yet most of Shadow Creek Ranch is within two2 miles, the range used in the A&M analysis. Many in the neighborhood took notice of the plant as a suspect after an offensive odor materialized last year. State officials are investigating possible sources, including a nearby landfill.
The company is confident the plant isn’t the source of the odor, spokesman George Nolan said, and has invited nearby residents for site visits.
For ethylene oxide and other hazardous materials, AkzoNobel often does more than federal safety and environmental standards require, Nolan said.
East of Degesch, tucked among the trees on Hooper Road, Syntech Chemicals occupies little more than three3 acres, and stores up to 50,000 pounds of formaldehyde solution, considered highly corrosive, toxic and flammable. It also has about a dozen other hazardous chemicals.
In 2002, fire ignited several 10,000-gallon tanks of methyl alcohol. Explosions destroyed most of the plant and sent a plume of black smoke toward the Sam Houston Tollway, snarling rush-hour traffic. Investigators attributed the blaze to an overheated oil reactor. Three months later, one of the tanks caught fire again. OSHA fined the company more than $100,000 for violating chemical process safety standards.
Three years ago, OSHA inspectors – prompted by a complaint – found hoses attached with hanger wires or patched with duct tape because clamps were damaged or missing. Employees told investigators that a worker damaged his eyesight after being sprayed with chemicals when he disconnected a hose.
Syntech Vice President James Gordon, in an email, attributed the 2002 fire to a faulty valve. The company rebuilt the plant, upgrading to the most modern equipment and safety features, he said.
Syntech then ran it for 11 years, OSHA found, without properly inspecting certain pressure relief valves, the last line of defense against fires, explosions and toxic releases.
The company reported that it fixed the problems from the 2013 inspections within one year, OSHA data shows. Gordon called the company’s compliance record in the last 15 years exemplary. “We at Syntech do not take safety lightly or as an afterthought,” he said.
Syntech, Degesch and AkzoNobel were in place long before Shadow Creek Ranch’s developers broke ground in 2001. None of the facilities will be visible above the treeline from the neighborhood’s new sports complex, under construction less than a mile from Syntech and a couple thousand feet from the other plants.
Chemical Breakdown
Reporters from the Houston Chronicle and researchers from the Mary Kay O’Connor Process Safety Center at Texas A&M worked together to create a first-of-its-kind study showing the potential harm to the public posed by hazardous materials at local businesses. The Chronicle obtained the chemical inventories, called Tier Twos, for about 2,500 businesses. Chemicals can be harmful in three key ways: flammability, reactivity and toxicity.
Researchers created a penalty multiplier based on the population within a two-mile radius of a facility. This information was pulled from the EPA and U.S. Geological Survey’s LandView database. Overall scores ranged from 2, with the lowest potential for harm, up to 14.
Type in your address in the map below to see if your home falls within a two-mile radius of a facility.
Dangers hit home
In Pasadena, east of Houston, residents who live near the Houston Ship Channel know that a myriad of chemicals could cause the next fire, explosion or release. Most are employed at the plants or at related service companies. For them, the pipes mean prosperity.
An October explosion at SunEdison (formerly known as MEMC) near Highway 225 burned four workers, one so severely that he needs long-term care. The blast resulted from a release of silane gas, one of several hazardous substances used to produce silicon wafers for the electronics and solar industries. A Harris County report said it appeared a valve leaked during maintenance.
Dangerous and potentially deadly
The Chronicle/A&M analysis considered hundreds of chemicals. Here are four used by facilities on the list of those having high potential for harm.
Source: National Center for Biotechnology Information, Sigma-Aldrich
The company didn’t respond to inquiries about the A&M findings, which placed it on the high-potential-harm list for another substance, an aluminum compound that ignites upon exposure to air.
After the fall explosion, spokesman Gordon Handelsman said earlier incidents had triggered enhanced inspection, maintenance and safety programs.
Fifteen workers went to hospitals after a release of corrosive fumes in 2008, and that same year, a loose pipe fitting resulted in a fire shutting down the silane unit for a week. In 2011, OSHA cited SunEdison for cracked valves in that unit and for failing to provide workers with a way to lock valves, exposing them to hazards.
Another Pasadena plant near the top of the A&M study, LyondellBasell (also known as Houston Refining), had a fire on April 8. No one was hurt, but schools and homes nearby were told to shelter-in-place for an hour. The plant had 11 violations during a 2009 OSHA inspection, many related to the mishandling of hazardous chemicals.
“We take our commitment to safe operations and compliance with federal and state regulations very seriously,” LyondellBasell spokesman George Smalley said by email. We regularly meet with our community and local officials and strive to be a good neighbor at all times.”
LyondellBasell can house more than 10 million pounds of methyl mercaptan. That’s more than 430 times the amount that spewed into an enclosed building at DuPont.
DuPont knew for years that hazards at its pesticide plant were capable of killing not only workers, but nearby residents, yet problems with clogged pipes and fire protection weren’t fixed, the CSB said last fall over company objections. The plant had not seen an OSHA inspector since 2007.
DuPont is closing the plant and spun off part of it into a new company, Chemours. It has up to 2.1 million pounds of toxic hydrofluoric acid, which tops the list of chemicals that advocates want industries to replace. When released, the acid forms a dense, rolling cloud of gas that hangs close to the ground, potentially sending lethal concentrations for miles. In 2012, a South Korean plant released 8 tons of it, killing five workers and triggering emergency treatment for more than 3,000 people in towns downwind.
Sergio Serrano, 76, and his wife have lived near such dangers for 40 years. They sleep to the ceaseless hum of chemical plants in Pasadena, like giant vacuum cleaners running in their back yard. Booming explosions or wailing sirens indicating chemical releases have pierced some nights – more times than Serrano can recall.
Nearby, there’s Goodyear, with sodium sulfide, a dangerous chemical in rubber production.
In 2008, a heat exchanger exploded at the plant, killing one worker with flying debris and spraying six others with toxic ammonia. OSHA fined the tire giant $43,000. A year earlier, OSHA had cited the plant for violating a rule that requires companies to take action in response to their own hazard analyses, and for having infrequent inspections of processing equipment.
Over the years, chemical giants have bought out Serrano’s neighbors and tried to buy his 860-square-foot home. No one has offered more than $15,000 and that’s not enough to afford a move, said Serrano, who is retired after years of washing hospital linens. So here he remains, looking out across weed-covered lots, sleeping to the hum.
‘Operating responsibly’
East of downtown, a park, a community center and three schools are within half a mile of Palmer Logistics, a chemical distributor.
The location epitomizes Houston’s haphazard zoning.
Palmer has held dangerous chemicals there for more than 30 years, but has not had a major release. It stores but does not process chemicals like paraformaldehyde. Nonetheless, chemical disasters have influenced president Brett Mears and his colleagues.
Palmer has decided to move all its hazardous chemicals to a new facility in an industrial area in Baytown, even though the lease is about 50 percent more expensive.
“Maybe the regulations say it’s acceptable to put a hazmat facility in a neighborhood,” Mears said, “but if you could be 5 miles from the closest houses, wouldn’t that be better?”
The Chronicle followed up with all the high-potential-for-harm facilities to learn what they do to prevent releases. Most responded with general comments about safety, maintenance and monitoring programs. Some went deeper. For example, the AkzoNobel facility in La Porte, which ranked highest in the A&M analysis, described precautions for triethylaluminum.
People who handle it are specially trained, wear customized, stringently tested protective suits and work with constant surveillance, site director Allen Tribble said. The company conducted research and safety studies to develop best-handling practices, including eliminating contact with air and moisture, which leads to fires.
The East Harris County Manufacturers Association weighed in on behalf of many facilities.
Craig Beskid, executive director of EHCMA, said its member companies regularly share best practices and assess hazards and risks, and use state-of-the-art technologies.
“We understand that the public wants to have confidence that our industry is operating responsibly, which is why we have multiple layers of safety protection in place,” Beskid said. “Assessing the risks without factoring in these safeguards is similar to assessing the risks of driving a car without factoring in speed, seat belts, anti-lock brakes, safety glass and other car safety improvements.”
At KMCO in Crosby, northeast of Houston, new owners made changes in recent years to improve safety.
The plant, near the sports complex, a restaurant and a church, stores organic peroxides, which can burn and explode. A similar substance called TATP is increasingly favored by terrorists because it can be made with household chemicals. Harris County sued the KMCO plant in 2008 for spills and fumes that gave neighbors headaches. The lawsuit ended in 2009, with a permanent injunction requiring KMCO to pay $100,000 in civil penalties and to give investigators easy access to the facility and prompt notification of releases.
The plant has dozens of OSHA violations since 2010, and an explosion in 2011 sent two workers to a hospital.
Kelly Nidini, the plant’s safety manager, said the company has significantly upgraded its facilities since 2013, has won multiple industry awards and will invest millions, primarily for safety and environmental concerns.
“We have no higher priority than ensuring safe and compliant operations,” Nidini said.
A city of hazards
Chemical companies, including Goodyear, sit across from a park near Pasadena. Goodyear ranked near the top of plants that pose a high potential for harm, according to a yearlong Houston Chronicle/A&M investigation. (Michael Ciaglo / Houston Chronicle)
Patrons and performers at the Pearl Theater near Pearland were surprised to learn that the warehouse nearby stores thousands of pounds of highly toxic aluminum phosphide. (Michael Ciaglo / Houston Chronicle)
The only signs of potential danger at Degesch America are two diamond placards near the front door, which warn first-responders about the hazards inside. (Michael Ciaglo / Houston Chronicle)
Many facilities around the region that handle or store hazardous chemicals look as innocuous as the Degesch warehouse. (Michael Ciaglo / Houston Chronicle)
A toxic gas leak at the DuPont plant in La Porte in November 2014 inspired the Chronicle to partner with Texas A&M to analyze chemical safety in the region. (Marie D. De Jesus/Houston Chronicle)
Crystle Rae Wise was one of four employees killed when methyl mercaptan leaked into an enclosed unit at DuPont. Photo courtesy of Clayton Thompson Funeral Home
Wade Baker, a shift supervisor at DuPont, also died in the accident.
Brothers Robert Tisnado, left, and Gilbert “Gibby” Tisnado were unable to escape the deadly fumes.
Mourners leave Grand View Memorial Park on their way to the Grand View Funeral Home during memorial services for the Tisnado brothers. (Johnny Hanson / Houston Chronicle)
In the aftermath of the November 2014 accident, Randall Clements, plant manager at the DuPont facility, expresses sadness over the loss of the company’s employees. (Marie D. De Jesus/Houston Chronicle)
Dan Tillema, the lead investigator for the U.S. Chemical Safety Board, discusses findings from the DuPont investigation. (Mark Mulligan / Houston Chronicle)
Lanette Soto, the sister of the Tisnado brothers, reacts to a CSB video aired during a public meeting in September 2015. (Mark Mulligan / Houston Chronicle)
A year after the accident at DuPont, flags were flown at half-staff in honor of those who died. (Cody Duty / Houston Chronicle)
The KMCO plant in Crosby stores organic peroxides, which can burn and explode. (Michael Ciaglo / Houston Chronicle)
A sign on the side of a KMCO storage tank reads: “Environment, Safety, Health, Profit.” (Michael Ciaglo / Houston Chronicle)
Pipes from the KMCO plant are visible to neighboring residents. (Michael Ciaglo / Houston Chronicle)
A worker at KMCO inspects one of the pipes. (Michael Ciaglo / Houston Chronicle)
Palmer Logistics stores products from 35 clients in the hazardous materials portion of its warehouse. The company is moving chemicals to a new facility in Baytown that will be farther from the public. (Michael Ciaglo / Houston Chronicle)
Jose Flores drives a pallet of toxic chemicals at Palmer through the warehouse. (Michael Ciaglo / Houston Chronicle)
Francisco Rodriguez moves some of the storage containers at Palmer to a truck. (Michael Ciaglo / Houston Chronicle)
Palmer Logistics President Brett Mears said he’s moving dangerous chemicals farther away from the public. (Michael Ciaglo / Houston Chronicle)
Barrels are marked for transport at Palmer, so workers understand what they’re handling. (Michael Ciaglo / Houston Chronicle)
Many of the prospective buyers at Shadow Creek Ranch never ask about the AkzoNobel plant nearby. (Michael Ciaglo / Houston Chronicle)
Hazards near two schools
At a facility in northwest Houston, Wyman-Gordon Forgings makes components for aircraft, missiles, power plants, and the nuclear and petrochemical industries. The company uses titanium, a volatile metal that caused two explosions in Los Angeles in 2010. Those blasts blew out fire engine windows, injured four firefighters and launched molten debris hundreds of feet.
On the other side of U.S. 290 from Wyman-Gordon, more than 5,000 students attend Arnold Middle School and Cy-Fair High School.
Company and school officials said they do not talk to each other about possible dangers from the plant.
In a statement, the school district said each campus has an emergency operation plan. “We conduct mandatory crisis drills for sheltering in place and evacuations,” assistant superintendent Nicole Ray said.
The facility isn’t without problems. In 1996, an explosion of a pressurized nitrogen tank killed eight workers, blew a jagged hole in the roof and propelled a piece of equipment that weighs as much as a Honda Civic more than 200 yards and more than 5 feet into the ground. The company agreed to pay $1.8 million in OSHA fines and promised to improve safety. In 2011, it was cited by OSHA for not recording worker accidents. The company paid a $2,000 fine. In 2014, OSHA cited it for exposing a worker to hazardous chemicals. The company paid a $100 fine.
Wyman-Gordon, like many large plants, has its own safety staff. The company has a full-time safety manager, a 31-member emergency response team, a certified EMT and a “confined space” rescue team.
It also recently started working with the Cy-Fair Volunteer Fire Department to improve the safe storage and use of titanium metal and to prepare for a fire. Company spokesman Jay Khetani described its recent OSHA violations as minor.
“The facility’s primary focus is the safety of its employees and ensuring that all members of its team return safely to home each night,” Khetani said.
Southeast of Wyman-Gordon on 290, Chem One is housed in a plain, single-story building. The company stores up to half a million pounds of reactive and toxic potassium permanganate.
Many facilities with hazardous chemicals look just as innocuous.
Near Oak Forest: International Paint, which can store an equal amount of flammable copper oxide.
Near Hobby airport: Buffalo Flange, with just as much toxic and flammable iron carbonyl.
Near George Bush Intercontinental Airport: Enduro Composites.
Walter Dunn lives about 2,000 feet from Enduro’s plant, which houses up to 5,000 pounds of cumene hydroperoxide – explosive and reactive and a chemical he’d never heard of.
“Small people have no say in where this stuff goes,” said Dunn, who was hunched over and working on his car on a warm spring day. His dog, Jack, greeted passersby, and down the street, teenagers played basketball.
If he wanted to move, Dunn said, where would he go?
“There’s no safe place,” he said. “It’s all over this town.”
Read part 2: An industry left to police itself
Mark Collette is a Houston Chronicle investigative reporter. E-mail: mark.collette@chron.com Twitter: @chronMC
Matt Dempsey is a Houston Chronicle data reporter. E-mail: matt.dempsey@chron.c
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Our Methodology
Want to learn more about how the Chronicle conducted this investigation?