The Trump Presidency
Government Shutdown

ANALYSIS ... Trump shutdown gambit was a folly, and he learned that Pelosi wasn’t bluffing

Burgess COMMENTARY

Peter Burgess

ANALYSIS ... Trump shutdown gambit was a folly, and he learned that Pelosi wasn’t bluffing WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump will emerge from the longest government shutdown in U.S. history politically weakened, his reputation questioned and his signature campaign promise still glaringly unfulfilled. The 35-day partial shutdown over the president’s demand for billions of dollars to build a wall along the U.S.-Mexico border was, in the end, futile. Facing defections within his own party, sagging poll numbers and public criticism for interrupted services, the self-proclaimed master dealmaker accepted an agreement that he had previously spurned and set an ignominious record that will remain part of his legacy. Days after Trump marked the midpoint of his term, the shutdown highlighted the disquieting side effects of his unconventional governing style and the trials that lie ahead for him in dealing with emboldened Democrats. The folly of the effort was readily apparent inside the White House, where aides had warned Trump even before the shutdown began that there was no avenue to success in the showdown with Capitol Hill. Democrats ran for office on preventing Trump from building the wall — and it’s hardly a popular idea even among Republican lawmakers. Advisers watched in shock as Trump declared in a December meeting with lawmakers that he would be ‘‘proud’’ to shut down the government. And when he ultimately did just that, they feared the messaging war had already been lost. ‘‘He was playing double-A ball against major leaguers,’’ said former Republican Rep. Tom Davis of Virginia, who once headed the House GOP’s campaign arm. By backing himself into the shutdown with no way out, Davis said, Trump displayed a lack of discipline from the start. The strategic deficit was only magnified by what allies saw as tactical errors. Trump spent the holidays tweeting from the White House rather than making public appearances to showcase his readiness to negotiate. He didn’t deliver a public address or visit the border to make his case until weeks had already gone by. Perhaps most crucially, he underestimated House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and the unity of congressional Democrats, thinking the Californian would be more amenable to a deal on the wall once she won the speakership. Trump’s message zigzagged sometimes by the hour. He maintained he was proud of shutting down the government and then tried to pin the blame on Democrats. One moment he signaled he was ready to concede the wall in favor of other barriers on the border, and the next he tweeted he was fighting for the wall as strongly as ever. It was emblematic of the dysfunctional White House culture he has fostered and the challenges that have been manifest on decisions big and small for two years. By the end of the shutdown, West Wing aides and outside allies of the president began to look at the seminal promise of Trump’s 2016 campaign as an immense — and unachievable — burden on his presidency. It was complaints that Trump appeared to be passing up his last, best opportunity to make good on his build-the-wall pledge that led Trump into the shutdown to begin with. Conservative commentators and House Freedom Caucus members fired off warnings that Trump’s base would sour on him if he didn’t use the last days of unified GOP control of Washington last year to try to get money for the barrier. But in his quest to appease his base, the president tarnished his standing with the American public. Overall, 34 percent of Americans approve of Trump’s job performance in a survey released this week by The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research. That’s down from 42 percent a month earlier and nears the lowest mark of his two-year presidency. ‘‘Hopefully now the president has learned his lesson,’’ Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer said in a press conference with Pelosi. The impasse was an early test for Pelosi after her return to the speakership, one that she appeared to pass handily. Democrats remained unified against White House efforts to divide the caucus, and they head into the next round of debate over border security funding determined to make good on their own 2018 promises to block Trump’s wall. As White House aides suggested that the shutdown had brought Democrats to embrace border ‘‘barriers,’’ Pelosi made clear her party remained resolved against the wall. ‘‘Have I not been clear?’’ she said. ‘‘No, I have been very clear.’’ Trump, characteristically, refused to concede that he’d conceded. Instead, he insisted he hadn’t caved to Democrats, and he threatened yet another shutdown even while bemoaning the last one’s impact on Americans. ‘‘This was in no way a concession,’’ Trump tweeted late Friday. ‘‘It was taking care of millions of people who were getting badly hurt by the Shutdown with the understanding that in 21 days, if no deal is done, it’s off to the races!’’ Associated Press writer Alan Fram contributed to this report. After Patriots’ AFC Championship win, NFL may reconsider overtime rules Rhode Island community suffers through days-long natural gas outage Driver allegedly travels ‘significant distance’ on Pike with man on hood Trump signs legislation that reopens federal government Warren’s wealth tax proposal could alter how Democrats talk about economic inequality Remembering the Inner Belt, the highway that never was Roger Stone’s indictment is strongest sign of ties between WikiLeaks, Trump The 37 best new restaurants in Boston and the suburbs For the president consumed with winning, a stinging defeat $60 million settlement proposed in child sex abuse lawsuit against New England Jesuit order, others Trump signs bill to end longest shutdown in US history President Trump on Friday night signed a bill that would reopen affected agencies, but the three-week deal provided no funding for a border wall, and talks over security will continue.More Newport, R.I., suffers through days-long natural gas outage In an eerie reprise of the Lawrence disaster, another community has been held hostage to a prolonged breakdown in the natural gas system.More For the president consumed with winning, a stinging defeat President Trump famously declared that in his administration the nation would become tired of all the winning. So Friday he tried a little losing.More Roger Stone’s indictment is strongest sign of ties between WikiLeaks, Trump The longtime confidant of President Trump was arraigned Friday on seven counts, including obstruction, making false statements, and witness tampering.More 50 years after Inner Belt protest, activists gather again Protests surrounding the highway — which would have sliced Greater Boston in two — were the main reason it was not built.More Apparent road rage incident on the Pike ends with a man riding on the hood of a car Two drivers were charged in what began as an apparent road-rage incident in Weston. More GLOBE MAGAZINE The 37 best new restaurants in Boston and the suburbs Dozens of inventive new spots to try, including fast-casual and top picks north, west, and south of the city. More SCOT LEHIGH Trump beats a humiliating retreat After an ill-considered government shutdown, the president caved in.More GROUND GAME Warren’s wealth tax proposal could alter how Democrats talk about economic inequality Democrats have campaigned for decades on the need to address income inequality, but a new proposal from the senator could change the terms of the debate. More STARTS & STOPS Get ready: The MBTA’s next fare hike is probably on its way Officials are scheduled to discuss fare proposals at a Monday meeting of the T governing board.More KEVIN PAUL DUPONT I SUNDAY HOCKEY NOTES What doomed Peter Chiarelli in Edmonton? The former Bruins GM was fired this week, less than four years after he took over the Oilers.More Julian Edelman, Sean McVay renew rivalry The Patriots star receiver and the Rams coach squared off in college when they played at rival Ohio schools.More $60 million settlement proposed in sex abuse lawsuit against New England Jesuits, others Boston attorney Mitchell Garabedian sued in federal court in Connecticut on behalf of 133 Haitian boys who said they were molested at a school there.More DINNER WITH CUPID Blind date: ‘I walked downstairs and recognized him’ Will a shared hometown be a plus or minus for these daters? More DAVE EPSTEIN Next week set to bring arctic air The temperature doesn’t look like it will be as low as what we saw at the beginning of this week, but it will still be one of the colder readings of the winter. More CHRISTOPHER MUTHER Puppy love in the Caribbean Tourists are lining up in Turks and Caicos for an opportunity to take adorable stray puppies to the beach. It’s become so popular some are calling the Turks “Puppy Island.” More Black women get a seat at the table with growing Queens Dinner Held every few months, The Queens Dinner is meant to be a place to cast off the armor one needs to survive in a world that so often dismisses and stereotypes black women. More ON THE JOB She’ll wait at the RMV so you don’t have to Susan Ho reentered the workforce to start her one-woman concierge company, with a little inspiration from Mr. Rogers. More ALEX SPEIER How Mike Mussina played a pivotal role in the Red Sox’ fortunes The Red Sox were in hot pursuit of Mussina as a free agent in 2000 but ultimately had to go to Plan B. More Real journalists. Real journalism. Subscribe to The Boston Globe today. © 2019 Boston Globe Media Partners, LLC