One Man’s Stand Against Donald Trump’s Election Conspiracies | “Denial” | The New Yorker Documentary
The New Yorker
Sep 16, 2024
903K subscribers ... 480,174 views ... 11K likes
After Trump claimed the 2020 Presidential election was “rigged,” a short documentary shows the effect of election conspiracies in the crucial jurisdiction of Maricopa County, Arizona, through the experience of one elected official.
Film by Paul Moakley and Daniel Lombroso
Still haven’t subscribed to The New Yorker on YouTube ►►
http://bit.ly/newyorkeryoutubesub
Transcript
- 0:00
- [gentle music]
- - [Man] Okay, again, please,
- no outbursts, please proceed.
- - [Man] And I'd just like another reminder please,
- that you do work for We The People.
- - Thank you. - Yes.
- - Yes. - 84% of poll workers
- zero confidence in our election process.
- You guys forget you represent We The People.
- - [Woman] Arizona needs to vote and count.
- - [Man] Thank you, again please.
- Please.
- - [Woman] The constitution
- of the United States of America
- and without us standing up under that,
- we have nothing.
- Nothing.
- - [Reporter] Voters in Arizona head to the polls Tuesday
- and in some of the key contests,
- 1:01
- leading Republican candidates have doubled down
- 1:04
- on far right conspiracies denying the results
- 1:07
- of the 2020 election.
- 1:09
- - [Reporter] Of course,
- 1:10
- Arizona has seen election related protests
- 1:12
- in the past, just two years ago.
- 1:14
- - [Trump] It is clear in Arizona
- 1:17
- that they must de-certify the election.
- 1:20
- You heard the numbers.
- 1:22
- And those responsible
- 1:23
- for wrongdoing must be held accountable.
- 1:27
- It was a corrupt election.
- 1:31
- - [Woman] Turn around and speak to everybody.
- 1:33
- We're gonna run 'em out of the building.
- 1:35
- - [Alex Jones] We know you're puppeteers.
- 1:36
- We know you follow your orders,
- 1:38
- and we're here to let you know that America
- 1:41
- is taking up the challenge of your attack
- 1:44
- and we're gonna double down on the ante,
- 1:46
- and you'll be defeated, and you'll be tried.
- 1:50
- Just like in Nuremberg, like the Nazis were.
- 1:53
- - [Man] The concept of truth itself is in debate here.
- 1:56
- This is right now a loyalty test
- 1:58
- and the GOP is largely going along
- 2:01
- with former President Trump.
- 2:03
- - The threats are against
- 2:05
- Republican Maricopa County supervisor Bill Gates.
- 2:09
- [eerie music]
- 2:18
- - [Man] It seems like a lot of voters
- 2:21
- are on edge right now,
- 2:23
- and as we hear reports of attempted voter intimidation,
- 2:26
- poll observers, poll watchers, there would be nothing
- 2:30
- that extremists and election deniers would like more
- 2:33
- than for voters to feel scared
- 2:36
- about whether they should vote.
- 2:37
- - And for us, actually from the threats perspective,
- 2:40
- unfortunately, there's still people out there
- 2:43
- spreading misinformation just in the last week
- 2:46
- about what some of our employees did
- 2:48
- in the 2020 election.
- 2:49
- And they're sending out videos
- 2:52
- saying that certain people violated laws,
- 2:54
- although this has been litigated over and over again.
- 2:57
- And guess what?
- 2:58
- Those employees who are called out
- 2:59
- by name on social media are getting some
- 3:02
- of the most vile threats, threatening emails, et cetera.
- 3:05
- So again, we're still dealing with this.
- 3:08
- I know like everyone else is, but this is a cancer.
- 3:12
- [eerie music]
- 3:16
- My first political memory is
- 3:18
- the 1976 presidential campaign.
- 3:22
- I spoke to my kindergarten class
- 3:25
- and I told them to all tell their parents to vote
- 3:27
- for Gerald Ford,
- 3:28
- 'cause if they didn't,
- 3:29
- their parents were gonna lose their jobs.
- 3:32
- And I would come home and watch C-SPAN.
- 3:36
- Kids dream about
- 3:37
- becoming a firefighter or an athlete.
- 3:39
- And this was always my dream was someday to be involved.
- 3:45
- When I turned 18, I was able to register as a Republican.
- 3:51
- I've always had this interest in emerging democracies
- 3:54
- in the former eastern bloc.
- 3:57
- I remember Ronald Reagan standing up
- 3:59
- and saying, you know,
- 4:00
- Mr. Gorbachev.
- 4:00
- - Tear down this wall.
- 4:05
- - That was always my dream to do that,
- 4:07
- fight for democracy there.
- 4:08
- [golf club whooshing]
- 4:09
- Then when I went to law school,
- 4:11
- I was in the Harvard Law School Republicans,
- 4:13
- the Federalist Society,
- 4:15
- and I wrote for the conservative journal there.
- 4:18
- [golf ball thudding]
- 4:19
- We called it the Conservative Trifecta.
- 4:21
- [Bill groaning]
- 4:22
- Ha ha.
- 4:24
- Oh.
- 4:28
- [Bill groaning]
- 4:32
- Ah.
- 4:33
- - [Woman] Okay.
- 4:35
- But this is a different Republican party
- 4:38
- than the party that I joined many, many years ago.
- 4:41
- - To represent --
- 4:42
- - Which is more valuable?
- 4:44
- Your money or your vote?
- 4:46
- Or your country or this world?
- 4:49
- Or the corruption that is taking over
- 4:52
- every single county in this nation.
- 4:56
- And then you look into your own soul
- 4:59
- and you look back at yourself in the mirror
- 5:01
- and realize that you are the cancer
- 5:04
- that is tearing this nation apart.
- 5:09
- Good day.
- 5:11
- - Thank you.
- 5:12
- Our next speaker is Kimberly Burlson,
- 5:15
- [phone beeping]
- 5:16
- - [Drew] Maricopa County Elections.
- 5:17
- This is Drew speaking.
- 5:18
- How can I help you today?
- 5:20
- - [Caller] You scumbag cheating Democrats.
- 5:22
- Huh, man?
- 5:23
- - [Drew] Look, if you have a concern
- 5:25
- I can actually -- - If it hurts you.
- 5:26
- - [Drew] I'd be happy to help you.
- 5:27
- - [Caller] We're gonna arrest
- 5:28
- all you people that are involved in this.
- 5:29
- You're gonna be hung or shot.
- 5:30
- That's what they do for traitors, sir,
- 5:32
- For treason.
- 5:34
- - [Woman] I'm sorry,
- 5:35
- I do not tolerate that kind of language.
- 5:37
- If you would like to talk to me
- 5:38
- in a civilized. - Someone should shoot you
- 5:39
- in the [indistinct].
- 5:41
- [dramatic music]
- 5:51
- - [Woman] They were filming and recording early voters
- 5:54
- calling themselves Clean Elections USA.
- 5:57
- They're recruiting people across the country
- 5:59
- to watch ballot drop boxes in an effort to detect fraud.
- 6:10
- - Our whole system here has been set up to keep
- 6:14
- the American people
- 6:16
- deaf, dumb, and blind to how the world operates.
- 6:22
- We've all seen stuff on the news
- 6:26
- and we know that there's a lot of trouble
- 6:28
- and we're just trying to save our republic.
- 6:32
- Our founding fathers gave us this job.
- 6:35
- They told us here, here's your constitutional republic.
- 6:40
- It's yours if you can keep it.
- 6:43
- - Oh my God. - And they gave us guns,
- 6:44
- and they gave us laws
- 6:46
- and we just need to make sure that we follow those
- 6:50
- because this is our country.
- 6:59
- Interesting.
- 7:13
- - In my chairman's speech, I said,
- 7:15
- I wanna make this the most transparent election
- 7:17
- in the history of Maricopa County.
- 7:21
- - [Man] For some reason we thought it might be good
- 7:23
- to talk about elections today.
- 7:26
- You know, I don't know how we landed on that.
- 7:28
- - [Man] So of course we have a recorder,
- 7:30
- Steven Richer.
- 7:31
- - [Pollster] You cannot bring a firearm within 75 feet of
- 7:34
- - 223 vote centers.
- 7:36
- It'll take us about 10 to 12 days
- 7:38
- to post those final results.
- 7:40
- - 13% by the end of the night.
- 7:41
- The rest of the world --
- 7:42
- - [Bill] The eyes of the world,
- 7:43
- The eyes of the world are
- 7:45
- on Maricopa County.
- 7:47
- - Our central facility is live streamed 24-7.
- 7:50
- Only a limited number of people have badge access to it.
- 7:53
- All of the wiring is exposed wiring,
- 7:55
- so you can see that it goes directly from a tabulator,
- 7:58
- not to the outside world,
- 7:59
- but directly to the election management server.
- 8:02
- Any computer box that is in that room
- 8:04
- is put inside another sealed box
- 8:06
- that is only open by a locked key,
- 8:08
- meaning that you couldn't just go around
- 8:10
- and stick a flash drive
- 8:11
- or anything of the like in there.
- 8:12
- And as mentioned before,
- 8:13
- at all times there are Republicans,
- 8:15
- Democrats working this process,
- 8:17
- but also Republican and Democrat
- 8:18
- official party observers
- 8:20
- who are there at any time
- 8:22
- that tabulation is actively occurring.
- 8:24
- - How bipartisan is this group?
- 8:26
- - Alleged voter intimidation.
- 8:28
- - Problems with chain of custody.
- 8:29
- A specific hotline?
- 8:31
- - [Reporter] Are you worried?
- 8:33
- - I wouldn't use the word worried.
- 8:38
- [people cheering]
- 8:42
- [upbeat music]
- 9:05
- [person breathing]
- 9:16
- I think these people out there
- 9:18
- have been told lies about
- 9:20
- people trying to steal an election.
- 9:22
- And I think it's even more than that.
- 9:24
- You know, it's sort of a fear of change
- 9:26
- and the way this country has changed.
- 9:29
- The way this has become, frankly,
- 9:31
- a more diverse, multi-ethnic democracy.
- 9:37
- I think that troubles some people.
- 9:38
- They want things to quote,
- 9:40
- go back the way they used to be.
- 9:46
- So what's really important for people to know is
- 9:48
- that we have 223 vote centers across Maricopa County.
- 9:52
- So even if lines do start
- 9:54
- to develop at the vote center you're at,
- 9:57
- you have 222 other options.
- 9:59
- In these close races,
- 10:00
- I don't expect for us to know
- 10:02
- the results this evening,
- 10:04
- but we anticipate by Friday we should have
- 10:06
- about 95 to 99% of the ballots counted.
- 10:09
- - [Reporter] I think that answers all my questions.
- 10:11
- - Okay. - Anything else?
- 10:12
- - Great.
- 10:13
- No, I don't think so.
- 10:14
- - We're now reporting live in Phoenix.
- 10:15
- Jamie Warren, ABC-15, Arizona.
- 10:20
- - How you feeling?
- 10:22
- - [Man] Nervous as hell.
- 10:24
- - Oh, well good.
- 10:24
- That's good luck, right?
- 10:25
- - [Man] No.
- 10:26
- [ballot machine whirring]
- 10:34
- - [Man] So what exactly is happening?
- 10:37
- - [Caller] So we're working on it and we're really
- 10:39
- proud of all of the work.
- 10:40
- - [Man] Why are you locked out?
- 10:42
- What's going on? - Well, so this one
- 10:44
- isn't a log off.
- 10:45
- So the other, the Burton Bar one is a logout.
- 10:47
- I think this one might be even more systemic.
- 10:50
- - Okay. - So we're not sure.
- 10:51
- And so that's why we have to have --
- 10:53
- - [Man] So we don't know.
- 10:54
- We don't know.
- 10:55
- [people chattering]
- 11:06
- - [Crew Member] Let me just double check.
- 11:07
- - We did want to come out
- 11:08
- and discuss one issue
- 11:09
- in about 20% of the vote centers.
- 11:12
- When people will go and they try
- 11:14
- and run the ballot through this tabulator,
- 11:17
- maybe one out of every five or so
- 11:20
- of those ballots they're not going through.
- 11:22
- But this is something we've prepared for.
- 11:25
- We will ask them to go here at door number three
- 11:28
- and place their ballot into this secure box.
- 11:31
- The key for everyone to understand
- 11:33
- is everyone is still getting to vote.
- 11:36
- No one is being disenfranchised.
- 11:38
- - How worried are you that, you know,
- 11:39
- an hour and a half in to today,
- 11:42
- you already have these real issues
- 11:45
- that could be manipulated
- 11:46
- or, you know, turned into reasons for people
- 11:48
- to once again not trust the system.
- 11:50
- - [Reporter] Did you account for the fact --
- 11:51
- - Yes. - That now people
- 11:52
- have to go get these ballots
- 11:53
- and bring them back here.
- 11:54
- - Yes. - And count?
- 11:55
- - If someone is alleging voter fraud,
- 11:57
- we have to have evidence.
- 11:58
- You can't just say it
- 11:59
- and, you know, make it in into being.
- 12:01
- No, I would not say that this is a disaster.
- 12:03
- This is a hiccup and we feel bad about this.
- 12:07
- We're sorry that this happened.
- 12:08
- - I'm just not confident in the people who we've elected
- 12:11
- to run these elections.
- 12:12
- - Yes. - I mean, they're not good.
- 12:14
- They're not good at their jobs.
- 12:16
- [people chattering]
- 12:20
- - These lines are a disgrace.
- 12:22
- We need people in handcuffs and leg irons
- 12:25
- - To the people of Arizona,
- 12:27
- stay online, don't leave.
- 12:30
- It's very, very unfair what's going on.
- 12:32
- - And who is this guy Bill Gates?
- 12:34
- This Mr. Rogers guy
- 12:35
- that walks in front of the microphone
- 12:37
- and there's no precision to what he's talking about.
- 12:39
- Two years later, we got the same issues.
- 12:43
- [reporter speaking in foreign language]
- 12:50
- [people chattering]
- 13:03
- [ballots whirring]
- 13:09
- [dramatic music]
- 13:17
- - His first rally
- 13:19
- as a presidential candidate was held over here
- 13:21
- at the Phoenix Convention Center.
- 13:24
- [people cheering]
- 13:27
- I was shocked to see
- 13:29
- offensive personal attacks on the media,
- 13:32
- particularly female reporters.
- 13:34
- This seemed to be a thing with him,
- 13:38
- but he was very effective in getting judges
- 13:43
- who I share a lot of, you know,
- 13:46
- ideological perspective, or sorry,
- 13:49
- I would say judicial, you know, views of judicial restraint.
- 13:52
- So I was very pleased to see that.
- 13:54
- And I did, yes, I voted for him in 2016.
- 14:03
- But in 2020 I was convinced
- 14:05
- that the election had been safe and secure
- 14:08
- and it was my duty to vote to certify that election
- 14:15
- - [Giuliani] Bill, it's Rudy Giuliani,
- 14:17
- President Trump's lawyer.
- 14:19
- I have a few things that I could talk over with you.
- 14:20
- Maybe we can get this thing fixed up.
- 14:22
- You know, I really think it's a shame that Republicans
- 14:25
- sort of were both in this kind of situation.
- 14:28
- Machine counts confirmed it.
- 14:30
- Hand counts confirmed it,
- 14:33
- the court system reconfirmed it.
- 14:37
- I don't think these elected officials,
- 14:39
- any one of them truly believed in this.
- 14:44
- They were going to literally give
- 14:46
- the President and the Senate
- 14:47
- the authority to throw us in jail
- 14:49
- because we weren't moving fast enough.
- 14:52
- Having our daughter call from college frantically
- 14:55
- and saying, dad, are you, are you going to jail?
- 14:59
- What is this that I'm hearing?
- 15:01
- [somber music]
- 15:08
- - They needed 16 votes to pass this.
- 15:10
- So that night, the 16th vote called me.
- 15:15
- Thank you Madam President, permission to explain my vote.
- 15:17
- - Please do.
- 15:18
- - My vote today is about prayerful patience.
- 15:22
- It's about resolving disagreements civilly.
- 15:24
- And these are things that I believe
- 15:26
- all of the senators can agree upon
- 15:28
- regardless of our respective votes.
- 15:31
- Today.
- 15:31
- - His 15 colleagues all voted to throw us in jail,
- 15:34
- and he stood up and said, no, I'm not going to.
- 15:37
- I mean, I'm like,
- 15:38
- we're in, you know, we're in Arizona here.
- 15:41
- And I can't believe this is happening
- 15:43
- to that this horrible thing would happen.
- 15:45
- But then also to see this courage
- 15:47
- and I mean like, what are the odds
- 15:50
- that all this would sort of coalesce?
- 15:56
- - [Reporter] Bill Gates,
- 15:57
- the chairman of the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors,
- 16:00
- had to go to an undisclosed location in connection
- 16:02
- with death threats levied against Gates
- 16:05
- for the handling of this month's midterm election.
- 16:09
- [dog barking]
- 16:11
- - [Bill] Hush.
- 16:19
- Thank you.
- 16:21
- - I love you. - Love you too.
- 16:24
- I know this is hard.
- 16:28
- [car whirring]
- 16:40
- I'm an incredibly lucky guy,
- 16:57
- but this, I can't do in front of,
- 17:00
- on camera.
- 17:01
- I'm on your camera.
- 17:02
- I can do it on your camera only,
- 17:06
- but I can't do it on anyone else's.
- 17:08
- So sometimes, you know,
- 17:09
- I release a little bit of frustration,
- 17:12
- or a little bit of emotion when I can.
- 17:15
- I certainly did last night.
- 17:18
- I have friends who know me, who I'm very disappointed in
- 17:23
- what they're doing right now, the way that they're attack.
- 17:25
- I can handle it, but they're attacking this process
- 17:28
- and they know better.
- 17:30
- And I'm struggling with that,
- 17:32
- but that's all right.
- 17:35
- [door clanking]
- 17:38
- - I'm sick and tired of imposters.
- 17:41
- We're sick and tired of fake news.
- 17:42
- We're sick and tired of fake politicians.
- 17:47
- We want our country back now.
- 17:49
- - How's it going down there, Andy?
- 17:51
- - [Andy] It's full.
- 17:52
- - It's full, okay.
- 17:56
- - [Group] I pledge allegiance to the flag
- 17:59
- of the United States of America
- 18:02
- and to the republic, for which it stands.
- 18:05
- - Morning, guys. - One nation,
- 18:07
- under God, indivisible,
- 18:09
- with liberty and justice for all.
- 18:13
- [people cheering]
- 18:15
- - [Group] Everybody.
- 18:17
- - Shame to hell to Maricopa County
- 18:20
- for dragging our fine Arizona
- 18:25
- straight to the toilet.
- 18:27
- - [Crowd Member] Again.
- 18:28
- - Thank you very much.
- 18:30
- Next speaker is --
- 18:31
- - You stand up under the constitution
- 18:33
- of the United States of America.
- 18:36
- And without us standing up under that, we have nothing.
- 18:39
- Nothing.
- 18:40
- - I had people coming out panic stricken
- 18:43
- because they were freaking out
- 18:45
- that their ballot was not accepted.
- 18:47
- They were told to throw it
- 18:48
- into the famous infamous box number three.
- 18:50
- - [Crowd Member] Those who make peaceful revolution
- 18:53
- impossible, make violent revolution necessary.
- 18:58
- - [Crowd Member] Let them be as snails
- 19:00
- that dissolve into slime.
- 19:01
- And as those who die at birth
- 19:03
- who never see the sun,
- 19:05
- God will sweep away both old and young.
- 19:08
- The godly shall rejoice in the triumph of the right.
- 19:13
- They shall walk in the bloodstained fields
- 19:16
- of slaughtered wicked men.
- 19:18
- Then at last, everyone will know that good is rewarded
- 19:23
- and that there is a God who judges justly here on earth.
- 19:29
- Thank you.
- 19:29
- - Thank you. - Thank you.
- 19:31
- All right, so that is,
- 19:32
- that now completes public comment.
- 19:34
- To those of you who are leaving right now,
- 19:36
- thank you so much for your time.
- 19:38
- Thank you for coming down on a Monday.
- 19:40
- - Traitor! - To testify.
- 19:42
- We appreciate.
- 19:43
- There's one thing I want to comment on.
- 19:45
- The integrity of my colleagues up here on the dais
- 19:48
- and the integrity of Stephen Richer were questioned
- 19:51
- over and over and over again.
- 19:54
- And I know this is not my seat.
- 19:57
- This is the people's seat that I sit in.
- 20:00
- This was not a perfect election, but it was safe and secure.
- The votes have been counted accurately.
- And I thank everyone for their attention today.
- And with that, I would entertain a motion.
- - Political hack jobs.
- Let it be on the record.
- You guys are horrible. - I apologize.
- I apologize for those who are watching
- at home - Now, we're talking for you.
- And your dishonesty
- and your lies. - You may not be able
- to hear what's going on here. - Lies, lies, lies!
- - [Bill] We're starting to leave
- the auditorium here. - You and your
- alternate reality.
- - All in favor, please say aye.
- Aye. - Aye.
- - All opposed?
- The motion passes.
- Thank you very much everyone.
- This meeting is adjourned.
- He said I'm scum
- and deserve to be tried for treason.
- And every single one of you scumbags.
- Bill Gates, you're the biggest piece of in Arizona.
- F-K you all.
- That's lovely
- [dramatic music]
| |