One was smooth, the other won: Rachel Maddow and MSNBC panel react to the vice presidential debate
MSNBC
7.4M subscribers
Oct 1, 2024
#TimWalz #JDVance #VPDebate
Rachel Maddow and a panel of her MSNBC colleagues share their overall reactions to the vice presidential debate between Governor Tim Walz and Senator JD Vance in which JD Vance gave a smoother presentation but ultimately lost the debate for his evasiveness and outright lies.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
- Download our new MSNBC app for the latest breaking news and daily headlines at a glance: https://www.msnbc.com/information/dow...
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
- MaddowBlog: https://www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
- ReidOut Blog: https://www.msnbc.com/reidoutblog
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
- Visit msnbc.com: https://www.msnbc.com/
- Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: https://link.msnbc.com/join/5ck/msnbc...
- Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
- Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
- Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
- #TimWalz #JDVance #VPDebate
Transcript
- 0:00
- YORK CITY.
- YOU SEE THE CANDIDATES BEING
- JOINED BY THEIR WIVES.
- USHA VANCE AND GWEN WALZ.
- I WOULD NOT DESCRIBE THEM AS
- EVENLY MATCHED BECAUSE THEY ARE
- SO DIFFERENT.
- SO DIFFERENT ON STYLE AND
- SUBSTANCE.
- VERY INTERESTED TO HEAR FROM
- THE SPIN ROOM, TO HEAR FROM ALL
- OF MY COLLEAGUES TO GET TO ALL
- OF THE ANALYSIS WE ARE GOING TO
- GET TO.
- I THINK THE BIG PICTURE TAKE
- AWAY ON THIS IS THAT ONE OF
- THESE CANDIDATES IS MUCH MORE
- SLICK.
- A MUCH MORE PRACTICED,
- PROFESSIONAL DEBATE STYLE
- SPEAKER AND THE OTHER CANDIDATE
- ONE.
- THERE WAS ONE BAD MOMENT FOR
- TIM WALZ IN THIS DEBATE WHERE
- HE GOT MIXED UP AND EMBARRASSED
- IN ANSWERING A QUESTION ABOUT
- EXACTLY WHAT MONTH HE HAD BEEN
- IN CHINA IN RELATION TO THE
- TIANANMEN SQUARE PROTEST.
- BUT THEN ON GUNS, ON JANUARY 6,
- ON OBAMACARE, ON THE ECONOMY,
- ON BLAMING EVERYTHING ON THE
- BORDER, BACK AGAIN ON
- 1:00
- HEALTHCARE, ON ABORTION, ON
- EVERY ISSUE ON SUBSTANCE.
- J.D.
- VANCE WAS VERY POLISHED AND
- VERY SLICK AND TIM WALZ BEAT
- HIM ON ALL THE SUBSTANTIVE
- POINTS.
- AT LEAST THAT WAS MY TAKE ON
- IT.
- I DO THINK THAT THERE WAS ONE
- VERY BLUNT, VERY EASILY
- DISPROVEN LIE ON A VERY
- IMPORTANT ISSUE THAT IS GOING
- TO BE REAL TROUBLE FOR J.D.
- VANCE COMING OUT OF THIS, WHICH
- IS HIM SAYING I NEVER SUPPORTED
- A NATIONAL BAN ON ABORTION.
- J.D.
- VANCE IS BLUNTLY ON THE RECORD
- AND ON TAPE SAYING I WANT
- ABORTION TO BE ILLEGAL.
- HIS ACTUAL QUOTE WAS I
- CERTAINLY WOULD LIKE ABORTION
- TO BE ILLEGAL NATIONALLY.
- NATIO
- NATIONAL ABORTION BAN WHEN THAT
- IS OUT THERE, IT IS SOMETHING
- THAT YOU NEVER WANT TO SHAKE ON
- 2:03
- THIS PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION
- AFTER ROE V. WADE.
- >>> SO, I THINK THAT J.D.
- VANCE SPENT THE NIGHT BUILDING
- A BEAUTIFUL FORT OUT OF PICKS.
- IT WAS PERFECT.
- AT THE END HE SNEAKED ON IT AND
- THE WHOLE THING FELL APART AND
- HE WHHAD TO WALK OUT OF THE ROO
- OVER THE BROKEN TOOTHPICKS.
- I THINK ROTHAT, GOD BLESS THE
- PEOPLE WHO WATCHED THE WHOLE
- THING AND STAYED LOCKED IN ON
- IT.
- I CHECKED IN WITH 20 PEOPLE WHO
- DO THIS AND WATCH IT FOR A
- LIVING.
- NO MATTER HOW YOU WATCHED THIS,
- IF YOU CAN NOT SAY WHAT
- HAPPENED IN 2020 AND THE ONLY
- REASON YOU ARE THERE BECAUSE OF
- WHAT HAPPENED IN 2020 IS
- BECAUSE SUPPORTERS WERE SENT TO
- HANG MIKE PENCE THEN YOU LOSE.
- WALZ HAD GREAT MOMENTS.
- HE BUILT -- I MEAN JD FANS
- BUILT IT, HE WAS SPEAKING AS
- THOUGH HE WAS GOING TO BE MITT
- 3:04
- ROMNEY'S VP.
- IT WAS A PERFORMANCE AMAZING
- AND DISCONNECTED FROM THE
- PERSON WHO HE IS RUNNING WITH.
- DONALD TRUMP.
- >> BUT STILL UNABLE TO SAY THAT
- TRUMP LOST THE ELECTION.
- >> AND IN THAT MOMENT.
- >> UNABLE TO SAY IT.
- >> AND >>IN THE MOMENT I THINK
- EVERYTHING THAT HE DID FOR 88
- MINUTES WAS LOST AND WIPED OUT
- BY THAT INABILITY TO TELL THE
- TRUTH.
- THAT, THAT MOMENT WAS THE
- MOMENT OF THE NIGHT.
- WAIT, WHY IS HE HERE?
- OH, RIGHT.
- THE MIKE PENCE THING.
- THAT HWAS THE MOMENT OF THE
- NIGHT.
- J.D.
- ADVANCES VERY GOOD AT THIS.
- THIS IS WHAT HE HAS BEEN DOING
- SINCE HE WAS IN COLLEGE,
- TALKING TO LIBS AND BEING WELL,
- I SORT OF AGREE WITH YOU HERE
- AND THIS IS THE OTHER PART OF
- IT.
- HE DID IT FINE.
- I THOUGHT WALZ ON SUBSTANCE,
- HEALTH CARE, VERY, VERY STRONG
- ON HEALTH CARE ON THE BASIC OF
- THE TAX CUTS AND WHO YOU ARE
- 4:01
- FIGHTING FOR.
- THESE ARE MEAT AND POTATOES.
- THE MOMENTS THAT BROKE ME.
- I DON'T KNOW ABOUT THE MEDIAN
- INFORMATION LEVEL OF THE
- VIEWER.
- THE LEVEL OF GASLIGHTING TO SAY
- THAT DONALD TRUMP SAVED THE
- ACA?
- HE SAVED OBAMA CARE.
- DID YOU MISS THAT?
- GOT UP ON NATIONAL TELEVISION
- AND SAID TRUMP SAVE TODAY IN A
- BIPARTISAN WAY.
- AND IT IS JANUARY 20th.
- AND THE BRAINED BASHED IN AND
- BLOOD ON THE CAPITOL AND 14
- DAYS LATER WE DID IT.
- >> HE DID NOT SHOW UP FOR THE
- TRANSFER OF POWER, BY THE WAY.
- IT IS REALLY RICH FOR
- DEMOCRATIC LEADERS TO SAY TRUMP
- 5:01
- IS A UNIQUE THREAT TO
- DEMOCRACY.
- WHAT IS THAT?
- IN WHICH THAT HAPPENED.
- AT THAT MOMENT WHEN TIM WALZ
- UDS REALLY CAN'T ANSWER THAT
- QUESTION?
- YOU REALLY CAN'T SAY THAT
- DONALD TRUMP LOST THE ELECTION?
- YOU CAN'T SAY THAT?
- THAT WAS THE MOMENT OF THE
- NIGHT.
- YOU MENTIONED SOME OF THEM.
- 25 MILLION UNDOCUMENTED
- IMMIGRANTS.
- MORE LIKE 15 OR 16.
- HE SAID HE REPORTEDLY LIED
- ABOUT SPRINGFIELD, AGAIN.
- AND THE DID IT SO INSISTANTLY
- THAT HE HAD HIS MIKE MUTED.
- THEY WERE BROUGHT IN BY AN APP
- AND THAT IS AN APP THAT
- IMMIGRANTS CAN USE TO COME IN
- AND GET A CERTAIN KIND OF VISA.
- THAT WAS LAUNCHED IN 2020
- UNDER, DRUMROLL, DONALD TRUMP.
- HE SAYS HE NEVER SUPPORTED A
- NATIONAL ABORTION BAN.
- I HAVE HERE A PRINTOUT THAT IS
- ALREADY CIRCULATING ALL OVER
- SOCIAL MEDIA OF -- THIS IS FROM
- 6:02
- THE CAMPAIGN WEBSITE OF J.D.
- VANCE WHEN HE RAN FOR UNITED
- STATES SENATE.
- HEADLINED 'END ABORTION' 100
- PRO-LIFE.
- SOCIETY IS A PLACE WHERE WE SEE
- CHILDREN AS AN INCONVENIENCE,
- ON AND ON AND ON.
- AND GAVE ONE OF THE QUOTES, HE
- WANTS TO SEE ABORTION TO BE
- ILLEGAL NATIONALLY.
- TO STOP WOMEN FROM TRAVELING
- ACROSS STATES TO OBTAIN
- ABORTION.
- HE ROIS IN FAVOR OF A FUGITIVE
- SLAVE ACT TO STOP ABORTION.
- HE BLAMED UNDOCUMENTED
- IMMIGRANTS FROM RISING HOUSE
- PRICES, RISING FOOD PRICES AND
- MAYBE GHOSTS AND BAD WEATHER.
- HE WAS BLAMING UNDOCUMENTED
- IMMIGRANTS FOR EVERYTHING.
- WALZ WAS SKILLFUL TO KNOCK IT
- DOWN AND HE WAS SPEAKING AS A
- GOVERNOR.
- HOUSING COSTS AND HOW IT WORKS.
- THE BIPARTISAN WAY TO SAVE
- HEALTH CARE WAS ABSOLUTELY
- ABSURD.
- HE SAID MOST OF OUR SOLARPANELS
- ARE COMING FROM CHINA.
- 7:01
- IT IS LITERALLY THE OPPOSITE.
- GOOGLE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION,
- 80% OF THE SOLAR PANEL COMES
- FROM, DRUMROLL, THE UNITED
- STATES.
- TRUMP PEACEFULLY GAVE UP POWER.
- FORGET JANUARY 6th AND COULD
- NOT ANSWER THE QUESTION DID
- TRUMP LOSE THE ELECTION.
- A SMOOTH LIE IS STILL A LIE.
- J.D.
- ADVANCES SMOOTH.
- HE SAID NOTHING MEMORABLE.
- THERE IS NOTHING CLIPPABLE IN
- WHAT HE SAID.
- JUST ALL SMOOTH BLAND LIES.
- HE GOT OUTDONE BY TIM WALZ.
- MAY BE AWKWARD, TOOK HIM AWHILE
- TO GET WARMED UP BUT HE WON THE
- DEBATE.
- HE HAD SUBSTANCE AND RELATABLE
- AND HE DID NOT GO IN THERE TO
- SLAY J.D.
- VANCE HE WENT IN THERE TO SHOW
- HIMSELF.
- HE SHOWED HIMSELF TO BE
- BIPARTISAN.
- REASONABLE, PRACTICAL.
- A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE COMPLAINING
- HE DID NOT KNOCK J.D.
- VANCE OUT.
- HE WAS NOT CRUEL.
- THAT WAS NOT HIS JOB.
- 8:00
- IT WAS OBVIOUS HIS JOB WAS TO
- SELL KAMALA HARRIS AS
- PRESIDENT.
- HE DID THAT
- VERY WELL.
- HE WON THE DEBATE.
- >> I WROTE A NOTE THAT HE WAS
- NOT ON OFFENSE AGAINST VANCE IN
- THE FIRST HALF OF THE DEBATE.
- HE CAME BACK AFTER THAT BREAK.
- AFTER THE BREAK AND WAS LIKE
- JUST DESTROYED HIM ON HEALTH
- CARE.
- THEN JANUARY 6th AND JANUARY
- 20th THING.
- I SCRATCHED OUT MY OWN NOTE.
- HE WAS MY NOT ON OFFENSE FOR VAN
- THE FIRST HALF AND THEN CAME
- BACK AND MORE THAN MADE UP FOR
- IT, LAWRENCE?
- >> YOU KNOW, HE WILL BE
- REMEMBERED FOR THAT FINAL
- EXCHANGE ABOUT, YOU KNOW, DID
- TRUMP LOSE THE ELECTION AND HE
- DOESN'T ANSWER.
- HIS TECHNIQUE IS TO NOT ANSWER.
- IT MAKES HIM THE VERY FIRST
- VICE PRESIDENTIAL PRESIDENT WHO
- DOES NOT KNOW WHO WON THE
- ELECTION [ LAUGHTER ]
- >> BUT.
- -- [ LAUGHTER ]
- >> A REPUBLICAN IS ALREADY IN
- OFFICE?
- >> IT CAME AT THE END OF A LONG
- LIST OF QUESTIONS THAT HE
- 9:03
- SIMPLY DID NOT ANSWER.
- >> IT IS A ONE-WORD ANSWER, YES
- OR NO.
- HE KEPT TALKING.
- HE WAS THEN ASKED WILL YOU,
- MARGARET BRENNAN ASKED HIM WILL
- YOU SEPARATE CHILDREN FROM
- PARENTS EVEN IF THE CHILDREN
- ARE UNITED STATES CITIZENS AND
- ADD COSTS TO THE NATIONAL DEBT
- WHAT IS YOUR SOLUTION TO THAT?
- NO ANSWER.
- WILL YOU MONITOR PREGNANCY?
- GOT AN ANSWER.
- HE SAID NO.
- HE SAID NO TO THAT.
- FINALLY, THERE WAS AN ANSWER.
- HE WAS THEN ASKED 'WHERE ARE
- YOU GOING TO SEIZE THE FEDERAL
- LANDS?
- >> THAT IS A REALLY IMPORTANT
- QUESTION.
- IF YOU ARE GOING TO BUILD
- ANYTHING IN AMERICA WE WANT TO
- KNOW WHERE IT IS AND A LOT OF
- 10:01
- PEOPLE DON'T WANT IT TO BE IN
- THEIR BACKYARD.
- >> AND OF COURSE, WALZ FOLLOWED
- UP ON THAT WHEN YOU SEIZE THE
- FEDERAL LAND FOR THE HOUSING IS
- THAT ALSO THE FEDERAL LAND YOU
- ARE SEIZING FOR THE DRILLING?
- [ LAUGHTER ] ARE THEY ALL GOING
- TO BE TOGETHER.
- >> AND DO YOU REMEMBER THE
- ANSWER?
- >> NO ANSWER.
- [ LAUGHTER ]
- >> AND THEN WE GET TO THE FINAL
- BIG O NO ANSWER WHICH IS ON A
- LOOP NOW OF, DID HE LOSE THE
- ELECTION.
- AND THE INABILITY TO ANSWER
- THAT.
- JUST ON THAT VERY SIMPLE DEBATE
- CONCEPT OF HERE IS THE
- QUESTION, AND YOU ANSWER IT, HE
- LOST SPECIFICALLY ON ANY
- SCORECARD WHEN YOU JUST GIVE
- HIM A 0.
- >> CAN I SAY SOMETHING ABOUT THE
- 11:02
- MOTOROLAERATOR.
- -- I DON'T PRETEND TO KNOW HOW
- EVERYONE WILL ACT TETO THIS, A
- LOT OF WOMAN IN POSITIONS OF
- AUTHORITY THAT SHOULD COMMAND
- RESPECT BY VIRTUE OF THE
- DYNAMIC WILL SEE THEMSELVES AND
- SOME DO, THE DISRESPECT AND
- TALKED OVER.
- I MEAN THERE WAS A MOMENT LIKE
- THAT WITH THEN VICE PRESIDENT,
- IN THE HARRIS/PENCE DEBATE WHEN
- SHE SAID 'I'M SPEAKING' THERE
- WAS A BELIEVE WHAT HE HAD TO
- SAY WAS MORE IMPORTANT THAN THE
- DEBATE RULES AND THE MODERATOR.
- THE SUBSTANCE IS WHEN HE WAS
- LIING ABOUT IMMIGRANTS IN
- SPRINGFIELD, OHIO, AGAIN.
- TIM T WALZ CALLED HIMSELF OUT O
- IT.
- NO, NO, NO, I AM NOT LYING, LET
- ME TELL YOU WHY I AM CALLING
- THEM ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS EVEN
- THOUGH THEY ARE NOT ILLEGAL.
- THEY SAID THANK YOU FOR
- EXPLAINING THE LAW.
- THAT IS NOT WHAT WE ARE ASKING
- 12:00
- YOU ABOUT.
- >> THAT IS WHEN HE COMPLAINED
- ABOUT BEING FACT CHECKED,
- SAYING THE RULES SAID YOU CAN
- NOT FACT CHECK ME.
- THAT IS ONE OF THE THING THAT
- IS IN THE VIDEO THAT WE WILL BE
- HEARING A LOT OF.
- NORAH O'DONNELL DID A FACT A
- CHECK INDIRECT AT THE END OF
- THE CLIMATE CHANGE DISCUSSION,
- THE DISCUSSION ENDED AND SHE
- JUST SAID DIRECTLY, THE OVERALL
- CONSENSUS THAT CLIMATE CHANGE
- IS HAPPENING.
- THAT IS THAT, BUT THEN WHEN IT
| |