Date: 2024-11-22 Page is: DBtxt003.php txt00023720
COMPANY: PATAGONIA
WHAT BUSINESS RESPONSIBILITY LOOKS LIKE!
Billionaire No More: Patagonia Founder, Yvon Chouinard Gives Away the Company
WHAT BUSINESS RESPONSIBILITY LOOKS LIKE!
Billionaire No More: Patagonia Founder, Yvon Chouinard Gives Away the Company
Original article: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/14/climate/patagonia-climate-philanthropy-chouinard.html
Peter Burgess COMMENTARY
Yvon Chouinard, the Founder of Patagonia is an unusual character, to say the least ... but a far better role model than most of the much more famous ... or is it, 'infamous'... wealthy folk who have also amassed huge fortunes.
Mr. Chouinard has been very creative in establishing a legal and organizational structure that reflects his values in a potentially sustainable way. This is not easy to do. From the article below:
'This family is a way outlier when you consider that most billionaires give only a tiny fraction of their net worth away every year,' said David Callahan, founder of the website Inside Philanthropy.I am not knowledgable enough about tax law to know whether this can be replicated relatively easily for other older folk with financial fortunes associated with family owned companies, but it would be good to see this replicated. The wealth of most of those with the largest fortunes seems to grow year after year without much active management by the owners ... Gates and Buffett were involved in developing the 'Giving Pledge' initiative, but it seems rather ineffective as a step towards a much more equitable world.
'Even those who have signed the Giving Pledge don’t give away that much, and tend to get richer every year,' Mr. Callahan added, referring to the commitment by hundreds of billionaires to give away the bulk of their fortunes.
Patagonia has already donated $50 million to the Holdfast Collective, and expects to contribute another $100 million this year, making the new organization a major player in climate philanthropy.
Peter Burgess
By David Gelles
Published Sept. 14, 2022 ... Updated Sept. 21, 2022
A half century after founding the outdoor apparel maker Patagonia, Yvon Chouinard, the eccentric rock climber who became a reluctant billionaire with his unconventional spin on capitalism, has given the company away.
Rather than selling the company or taking it public, Mr. Chouinard, his wife and two adult children have transferred their ownership of Patagonia, valued at about $3 billion, to a specially designed trust and a nonprofit organization. They were created to preserve the company’s independence and ensure that all of its profits — some $100 million a year — are used to combat climate change and protect undeveloped land around the globe.
The unusual move comes at a moment of growing scrutiny for billionaires and corporations, whose rhetoric about making the world a better place is often overshadowed by their contributions to the very problems they claim to want to solve.
At the same time, Mr. Chouinard’s relinquishment of the family fortune is in keeping with his longstanding disregard for business norms, and his lifelong love for the environment.
'Hopefully this will influence a new form of capitalism that doesn’t end up with a few rich people and a bunch of poor people,' Mr. Chouinard, 83, said in an exclusive interview. 'We are going to give away the maximum amount of money to people who are actively working on saving this planet.'
Patagonia will continue to operate as a private, for-profit corporation based in Ventura, Calif., selling more than $1 billion worth of jackets, hats and ski pants each year. But the Chouinards, who controlled Patagonia until last month, no longer own the company.
In August, the family irrevocably transferred all the company’s voting stock, equivalent to 2 percent of the overall shares, into a newly established entity known as the Patagonia Purpose Trust.
The trust, which will be overseen by members of the family and their closest advisers, is intended to ensure that Patagonia makes good on its commitment to run a socially responsible business and give away its profits. Because the Chouinards donated their shares to a trust, the family will pay about $17.5 million in taxes on the gift.
The interior of a Patagonia store with women and men’s clothes hanging as a woman shops in the distance. ...Credit: Laure Joliet for The New York Times
The Chouinard family irrevocably transferred all the company’s voting stock into a newly established entity known as the Patagonia Purpose Trust in August.
The Chouinards then donated the other 98 percent of Patagonia, its common shares, to a newly established nonprofit organization called the Holdfast Collective, which will now be the recipient of all the company’s profits and use the funds to combat climate change. Because the Holdfast Collective is a 501(c)(4), which allows it to make unlimited political contributions, the family received no tax benefit for its donation.
'There was a meaningful cost to them doing it, but it was a cost they were willing to bear to ensure that this company stays true to their principles,' said Dan Mosley, a partner at BDT & Co., a merchant bank that works with ultrawealthy individuals including Warren Buffett, and who helped Patagonia design the new structure. 'And they didn’t get a charitable deduction for it. There is no tax benefit here whatsoever.'
Barre Seid, a Republican donor, is the only other example in recent memory of a wealthy business owner who gave away his company for philanthropic and political causes. But Mr. Seid took a different approach in giving 100 percent of his electronics company to a nonprofit organization, reaping an enormous personal tax windfall as he made a $1.6 billion gift to fund conservative causes, including efforts to stop action on climate change.
By giving away the bulk of their assets during their lifetime, the Chouinards — Yvon, his wife Malinda, and their two children, Fletcher and Claire, who are both in their 40s — have established themselves as among the most charitable families in the country.
'This family is a way outlier when you consider that most billionaires give only a tiny fraction of their net worth away every year,' said David Callahan, founder of the website Inside Philanthropy.
'Even those who have signed the Giving Pledge don’t give away that much, and tend to get richer every year,' Mr. Callahan added, referring to the commitment by hundreds of billionaires to give away the bulk of their fortunes.
Patagonia has already donated $50 million to the Holdfast Collective, and expects to contribute another $100 million this year, making the new organization a major player in climate philanthropy.
Mr. Mosley said the story was unlike any other he had seen in his career. 'In my 30 plus years of estate planning, what the Chouinard family has done is really remarkable,' he said. 'It’s irrevocably committed. They can’t take it back out again, and they don’t want to ever take it back out again.'
For Mr. Chouinard, it was even simpler than that, providing a satisfactory resolution to the matter of succession planning.
'I didn’t know what to do with the company because I didn’t ever want a company,' he said from his home in Jackson, Wyo. 'I didn’t want to be a businessman. Now I could die tomorrow and the company is going to continue doing the right thing for the next 50 years, and I don’t have to be around.'
‘This might actually work’
Yvon Chouinard and his friend Rick Ridgeway stand in a garden in front
of greenhouses with mountains in the background.
'Hopefully this will influence a new form of capitalism that doesn’t end up with a few rich people and a bunch of poor people,' said Mr. Chouinard.Credit...Meridith Kohut for The New York Times
In some ways, the forfeiture of Patagonia is not terribly surprising coming from Mr. Chouinard.
As a pioneering rock climber in California’s Yosemite Valley in the 1960s, Mr. Chouinard lived out of his car and ate damaged cans of cat food that he bought for five cents apiece.
Even today, he wears raggedy old clothes, drives a beat up Subaru and splits his time between modest homes in Ventura and Jackson, Wyo. Mr. Chouinard does not own a computer or a cellphone.
Patagonia, which Mr. Chouinard founded in 1973, became a company that reflected his own idealistic priorities, as well as those of his wife. The company was an early adopter of everything from organic cotton to on-site child care, and famously discouraged consumers from buying its products, with an advertisement on Black Friday in The New York Times that read, 'Don’t Buy This Jacket.'
The company has given away 1 percent of its sales for decades, mostly to grass roots environmental activists. And in recent years, the company has become more politically active, going so far as to sue the Trump administration in a bid to protect the Bears Ears National Monument.
Yet as Patagonia’s sales soared, Mr. Chouinard’s own net worth continued to climb, creating an uncomfortable conundrum for an outsider who abhors excessive wealth.
'I was in Forbes magazine listed as a billionaire, which really, really pissed me off,' he said. 'I don’t have $1 billion in the bank. I don’t drive Lexuses.'
The Forbes ranking, and then the Covid-19 pandemic, helped set in motion a process that would unfold over the past two years, and ultimately lead to the Chouinards giving away the company.
In mid-2020, Mr. Chouinard began telling his closest advisers, including Ryan Gellert, the company’s chief executive, that if they couldn’t find a good alternative, he was prepared to sell the company.
'One day he said to me, ‘Ryan, I swear to God, if you guys don’t start moving on this, I’m going to go get the Fortune magazine list of billionaires and start cold calling people,’' Mr. Gellert said. 'At that point we realized he was serious.'
Patagonia has become more politically active, going so far as to sue the
Trump administration in a bid to protect the Bears Ears National Monument.
Credit...Laure Joliet for The New York Times
Using the code name Project Chacabuco, a reference to a fishing spot in Chile, a small group of Patagonia lawyers and board members began working on possibilities.
Over the next several months, the group explored a range of options, including selling part or all of the company, turning Patagonia into a cooperative with the employees as owners, becoming a nonprofit, and even using a special purpose acquisition company, or SPAC.
'We kind of turned over every stone, but there just weren’t really any good options that could accomplish their goals,' said Hilary Dessouky, Patagonia’s general counsel.
The easiest paths, selling the company or taking it public, would have given Mr. Chouinard ample financial resources to fund conservation initiatives. That was the strategy pursued by his best friend, Doug Tompkins, founder of the clothing companies Esprit and The North Face.
But Mr. Chouinard had no faith that Patagonia would be able to prioritize things like worker well-being and funding climate action as a public company.
'I don’t respect the stock market at all,' he said. 'Once you’re public, you’ve lost control over the company, and you have to maximize profits for the shareholder, and then you become one of these irresponsible companies.'
They also considered simply leaving the company to Fletcher and Claire. But even that option didn’t work, because the children didn’t want the company.
'It was important to them that they were not seen as the financial beneficiaries,' Mr. Gellert said. 'They felt very strongly about it. I know it can sound flippant, but they really embody this notion that every billionaire is a policy failure.'
Finally, the legal team and board members landed on a solution.
In December, at a daylong meeting in the hills above Ventura, the entire team came together for the first time since the pandemic began. Meeting outside, surrounded by oak trees and avocado orchards, all four Chouinards, along with their team of advisers, agreed to move ahead.
‘We still had a million and one things to figure out, but it started to feel like this might actually work,’ Mr. Gellert said.
‘The ideal solution’
Mr. Chouinard filmed an announcement for his employees at home in Wyoming. By giving away the bulk of their assets during their lifetime, the Chouinards have established themselves as among the most charitable families in the country. Credit...Natalie Behring for The New York Times
Now that the future of Patagonia’s ownership is clear, the company will have to make good on its lofty ambitions to simultaneously run a profitable corporation while tackling climate change.
Some experts caution that without the Chouinard family having a financial stake in Patagonia, the company and the related entities could lose their focus. While the children remain on Patagonia’s payroll and the elder Chouinards have enough to live comfortably on, the company will no longer be distributing any profits to the family.
'What makes capitalism so successful is that there’s motivation to succeed,' said Ted Clark, executive director of the Northeastern University Center for Family Business. 'If you take all the financial incentives away, the family will have essentially no more interest in it except a longing for the good old days.'
As for how the Holdfast Collective will distribute Patagonia’s profits, Mr. Chouinard said much of the focus will be on nature-based climate solutions such as preserving wild lands. And as a 501(c)(4), the Holdfast Collective will also be able to build on Patagonia’s history of funding grass roots activists but it could also lobby and donate to political campaigns.
For the Chouinards, it resolves the question of what will happen to Patagonia after its founder is gone, ensuring that the company’s profits will be put to work protecting the planet.
'I feel a big relief that I’ve put my life in order,' Mr. Chouinard said. 'For us, this was the ideal solution.'
David Gelles is a correspondent on the Climate desk, covering the intersection of public policy and the private sector. Follow him on LinkedIn and Twitter. @dgelles
A version of this article appears in print on Sept. 15, 2022, Section B, Page 1 of the New York edition with the headline: Billionaire Gives Away His Company to Fight Climate Change.