Date: 2025-01-15 Page is: DBtxt003.php txt00025190
US POLITICS
SENATOR FEINSTEIN
For an Ailing Feinstein, a Fight Over the Family Fortune ... As Dianne Feinstein, 90, struggles to function in the Senate, a dispute within her family over control of her late husband’s estate is another difficult chapter at the end of a long career.
SENATOR FEINSTEIN
For an Ailing Feinstein, a Fight Over the Family Fortune ... As Dianne Feinstein, 90, struggles to function in the Senate, a dispute within her family over control of her late husband’s estate is another difficult chapter at the end of a long career.
Original article: https://www.nytimes.com/2023/08/03/us/feinstein-husband-estate-family-fortune.html
Peter Burgess COMMENTARY
Peter Burgess
Aug. 3, 2023
For years, Senator Dianne Feinstein of California has been engaged in a long and painful public drama about her health and ability to do her job, as she winds down a storied career as a lawmaker and a former mayor of San Francisco.
Now, Senator Feinstein is also navigating an increasingly bitter legal and financial conflict that pits her and her daughter, Katherine Feinstein, against the three daughters of her late husband Richard C. Blum, who was a wealthy financier.
In one legal dispute, the family is fighting over what’s described as Senator Feinstein’s desire to sell a beach house in an exclusive neighborhood in Stinson Beach, north of San Francisco. In another disagreement, the two factions are at odds over access to the proceeds of Mr. Blum’s life insurance, which Senator Feinstein says she needs to pay for her growing medical expenses.
For those close to Senator Feinstein, the struggle over Mr. Blum’s estate has exacerbated a recent and regrettable chapter that has marred the twilight of a long and successful public life and that has raised concerns about her ability to manage her own affairs.
“The financial conflict is another element that makes the end of her career sad to people who have known her in the high points of her career,” said Jerry Roberts, author of the biography “Dianne Feinstein: Never Let Them See You Cry.” It was published in 1994, two years after she was elected to the Senate.
Raised in affluence, Senator Feinstein has long been among the wealthiest members of Congress. She was rich in her own right in 1980 when she married Mr. Blum. After she entered the Senate, she placed securities into a blind trust that is valued at between $5 million and $25 million, according to her most recent financial disclosure required of lawmakers.
Combined, the couple’s fortunes flourished to an extent that eclipsed even the senator’s prior standard of living. Her main residence is a 9,500-square-foot mansion in the upscale San Francisco neighborhood of Pacific Heights. Their vacation homes, until recently, included the 36-acre Bear Paw Ranch in Aspen, Colo., which sold in March for more than $25 million, and a seven-bedroom Lake Tahoe compound that sold in late 2021 for a reported $36 million. Current holdings include a property on the Hawaii island of Kauai and a home in Washington, D.C.
A Divided Congress
Joe Manchin: Senator Joe Manchin III, Democrat of West Virginia, told a local news station that he “would think very seriously” about leaving the Democratic Party and becoming an independent. How Old Is Too Old?: Two troubling moments involving Senators Dianne Feinstein and Mitch McConnell thrust questions about aging in office into the national conversation. John Fetterman: The senator spoke in a candid interview about life in Washington after a stroke and a bout of depression, congressional dysfunction and his aversion to business suits. Senate Frenemies: Senator Steve Daines of Montana, the Republican campaign chief, is taking aim at his home-state colleague Senator Jon Tester, a Democrat in one of 2024’s biggest races. It’s a bit awkward.
Among the backdrops to the fight over Mr. Blum’s estate, however, are questions about the extent of his fortune, as well as the out-of-pocket cost of home health care that Senator Feinstein has received since her bout with shingles earlier this year.
During his lifetime, Mr. Blum, Senator Feinstein’s third husband and a private equity magnate, was often referred to in public accounts as a billionaire. However, people familiar with the family’s finances dispute that characterization and say that Mr. Blum’s wealth was less than some heirs had expected. Mr. Blum’s friends said that the pandemic cut deeply into his investments, particularly his extensive holdings in hotels.
Senator Feinstein, 90 and in her sixth term in the Senate, has long been in frail health with increasing memory and cognition issues. When she returned to work earlier this year after a monthslong absence because of shingles and various complications, her further decline shocked colleagues. She has relied on a cadre of aides in order to function in the Senate, even as she has resisted calls to relinquish her seat before her term expires after next year’s election.
Ms. Feinstein, who is seated and wearing a blue jacket, kisses Mr. Blum, who is standing with his right hand on her left shoulder. Senator Feinstein sharing a moment with her husband, Richard Blum, as former Senator Barbara Boxer looked on.Credit...Jim Wilson/The New York Times
Katherine Feinstein, 66, Senator Feinstein’s only child, who has power of attorney over her mother’s legal affairs, filed two lawsuits against Senator Feinstein’s co-trustees. The first lawsuit, over the beach house, says the property is in disrepair, that Senator Feinstein no longer wishes to use it, and that she wants to sell it this summer or fall.
Earlier in her career, the beach house offered a special refuge from the rough-and-tumble world of politics, and she retreated there after losing the 1990 race for governor of California. The three-bedroom home facing Bolinas Lagoon occupies nearly a half-acre of sand in a gated community whose residents over the years have ranged from old-money San Franciscans and hippie artists to celebrities like the novelist Danielle Steel and members of The Grateful Dead. In May, a house of comparable size in the same community sold for more than $6 million.
Image An aerial view of a seaside neighborhood. A satellite image of Senator Feinstein’s neighborhood in Stinson Beach, Calif., north of San Francisco.Credit...Google Earth
The suit also accused Mr. Blum’s daughters of seeking to use the beach house at Senator Feinstein’s expense and to limit her ability to sell off parts of the trust in order to increase the value of their inheritance after Senator Feinstein’s death.
The second lawsuit, which challenges whether the trustees were properly appointed, concerns Mr. Blum’s life insurance proceeds and claims that the funds, which are supposed to be disbursed through a trust, have been held back by the trustees. The suit says that Senator Feinstein has “incurred significant medical expenses” and that despite Mr. Blum’s “intent to support his spouse after his death, the purported trustees have refused to make distributions to reimburse Senator Feinstein’s medical expenses.”
In response, a Bay Area lawyer representing the two trustees — Michael R. Klein, a longtime lawyer for Mr. Blum, and Marc T. Scholvinck, who was chief financial officer of Mr. Blum’s private equity firm — said the two had never refused to pay any money to Senator Feinstein. The lawyer, Steven P. Braccini, also suggested that Katherine Feinstein, a former Superior Court judge in San Francisco who is now on the city’s fire commission, was acting out of personal interests and not out of those of her mother.
“My clients are perplexed by this filing,” Mr. Braccini said in a statement. “Richard Blum’s trust has never denied any disbursement to Senator Feinstein, let alone for medical expenses.”
Katherine Feinstein did not respond to requests for comment.
The statement said that the trustees have not been provided with documentation showing that Katherine Feinstein had been appointed power of attorney. And, in an apparent attempt to raise questions about Senator Feinstein’s capacity to represent her own interests in the lawsuit, it said: “Nor has Katherine made it clear, either in this filing or directly to my clients, why a sitting United States senator would require someone to have power of attorney over her.”
The statement went on: “While my clients are deeply concerned, we all remain hopeful that this is simply a misunderstanding that can be quickly resolved, rather than a stepdaughter engaging in some kind of misguided attempt to gain control over trust assets to which she is not entitled.”
Katherine Feinstein, with dark glasses, speaks at a microphone behind a podium with a matching black suit. ... Katherine Feinstein, Senator Feinstein’s only child, has power of attorney over her mother’s legal affairs and has filed two lawsuits on her behalf.Credit...Lea Suzuki/San Francisco Chronicle, via Associated Press
Despite the family’s wealth, friends said, there has been some anxiety over the distribution of assets and concerns from the senator and her daughter about the cost of the extensive home care that Senator Feinstein has required, which may not be covered by insurance.
When she was homebound in San Francisco recovering from shingles, housekeepers and home health aides cared for Senator Feinstein full time under her daughter’s oversight, according to more than a half dozen family friends and advisers who asked to remain anonymous because they were not authorized to publicly discuss the senator’s family affairs.
When she returned to work earlier this year, a longstanding health aide accompanied Senator Feinstein to Washington, two friends said. The senator’s daughter and son-in-law have helped her manage her personal finances for many years, the friends added.
Adam Russell, a representative for Senator Feinstein, said, “This is a private legal matter. Senator Feinstein and her office won’t have any comment.”
Willie Brown, a former mayor of San Francisco and a longtime friend of the Feinstein family, said that the feud over finances probably reflects longstanding animosity between Katherine Feinstein and Mr. Blum’s three daughters. “There would not have been any issue, frankly, if there was mutual love between all the people,” he said.
Mr. Brown continued, “I frankly would rely upon the clarity of thought that the daughter has demonstrated in the past.” He called Katherine Feinstein a “brilliant woman, a brilliant judge” and said she “would not have taken whatever steps she has taken without some serious need to have that done, frankly, on behalf of her mother.”
Tim Arango is a Los Angeles correspondent. Before moving to California, he spent seven years as Baghdad bureau chief and also reported on Turkey. He joined The Times in 2007 as a media reporter. More about Tim Arango
Shawn Hubler is a national correspondent based in California. Before joining The Times in 2020 she spent nearly two decades covering the state for The Los Angeles Times as a roving reporter, columnist and magazine writer, and shared three Pulitzer Prizes won by the paper's Metro staff. More about Shawn Hubler
A version of this article appears in print on Aug. 6, 2023, Section A, Page 17 of the New York edition with the headline: For Ailing Feinstein, Family Fortune Is Root Of a Bitter Legal Fight. Order Reprints | Today’s Paper | Subscribe
Editors’ Picks
- For Younger Workers, Job Hopping Has Lost Its Stigma. Should It?
- ‘We’re All Water-Bottle Freaks’
- 130 Degrees and Rising: How Kitchen Workers Are Dealing With Record Heat