TRANSCRIPT
SECTION 19
HOW WILL AI AFFECT CHINA
AND AMERICA'S ECONOMIC WAR
Version 1 ... February 2025
- I like the climate I like the ocean I like it's just a people are very
- friendly it's a very attractive place for me but New
- York City is also even don't have those qualities you know I like New Orleans I
- like New York I like San Francisco the other thing I I wanted to bring up
- How Will AI Affect China and America’s Economic War?
- 2:33:24
- right now isn't so much a a policy issue but just a a a broader domestic economic
- issue going forward and one that I think your Marxist or marxian you've been
- using that word analysis might be really helpful with it also connects to deep
- seek automation electric vehicles and that is the role of Advan ments in AI
- in the competition between China and the United States and also just the overall
- health of our domestic Workforce I don't know quite how to get at what it is I would want to
- 2:34:06
- say uh about that China has demonstrated now and I believe this is true to almost
- every reasonable person whether they like China or not uh whether they
- support what China is or don't they have demonstrated that
- economic growth can be achieved faster in their kind of system
- than it can in any other country and that is a momentous I mean
- just that's a momentous achievement over the last 30 to 40
- years they have consistently grown as measured by their
- GDP two to three times faster than the United
- 2:35:00
- States I must remind people even though they hate to hear it that before this
- Speedy growth the Soviet Union accomplished Speedy
- growth not as fast but Speedy growth so that
- the painful reality so painful it can't be spoken is that the 20th and 21st
- centuries demonstrated the growth potential and
- the growth actuality most effectively in the Soviet
- Union and China if you look at the Soviet Union as the first experiment in what I'm about
- to describe as their economic system and China as the
- second right Russia starts in 1917 uh China in 1949 that's quite a
- 2:36:00
- difference but by now we have 70 years roughly 70 years the Soviet Union and
- now 70 years of China and the Chinese grow faster more
- spectacular than the Russian the Russian were a system of
- State Enterprises throughout industry and a growing proportion of
- State Enterprises in
- agriculture and very little scope for capitalist
- Enterprises throughout that time not zero that's an American fantasy but
- small China is completely
- different China made a decision
- 2:37:00
- afterm to become a hybrid to be partly
- state-owned and operated Enterprises
- half and the other half private capitalist Enterprises both Chinese and
- external allowed so that I think it's fair to say
- that China represents a hybrid trying to
- combine both the benefits of a private
- capitalism Model United States and of a state-owned and operated
- enterprise system example the Soviet Union they
- really are a 5050
- split with the hybrid of these two systems
- 2:38:01
- overseen by a Communist party and a powerful State apparatus controlled by
- that party [Music] and they've
- achieved really an unspeakable story
- let me give you one statistic just to get put in your head the GDP of the United States 28
- trillion bucks more or less the GDP of
- Russia our former Arch Enemy today is three or4
- trillion no content no nothing and that was always true I only in
- the Cold War Legacy mentality of the United States did Russia
- Loom you know
- 2:39:03
- Silly economic nonsense anyway that's not true with
- China China's GDP now 18 19 20 trillion dollar
- way different from Russia and equally so from anywhere
- else Britain's GDP I don't know four five six trillion something like that
- very small bigger than Russia though what bigger than Russia probably bigger than Russia yeah and and Russia fighting
- NATO means Russia's fighting Britain France Germany Italy is refusing that's
- but look what China has done China was one of the poorest countries on the planet in
- 1949 and is now number two unquestionably number two after the
- 2:40:04
- United States and each year closing the Gap
- um that is an astounding achieve is very very hard for
- me not to dwell on it but one of its
- components and one of the reasons it it has the achievement will go take us to
- the technology issue a powerful Communist Party ruling
- a powerful State apparatus supervising this
- hybrid can do something quickly and
- efficiently that the United States either can't do or can't do quickly and
- efficiently it can mobilize the entire economy to achieve certain
- 2:41:05
- priorities it can mobilize the government sector in its ways and the
- private sector in its ways it can force them to collaborate and coordinate so
- that the resources each has are brought together to attack a
- problem it does not respect private profit as the
- priority which is what happens here it does not believe the private has to be
- given Primacy in some sense as happens here it doesn't have a government filled
- with people who believe that the private is in some sense the more important the more patriotic the more deserving the
- more what it doesn't have any of that in fact it has the
- 2:42:00
- other one of the elements of Socialism or
- communism that has a real effect here is that the people involved in the public
- sector believe in it respect it
- even value it higher than the private in recent years in China you
- have seen programs punishing leading private capitalists
- Jack Mah and others like that kind of dressing them
- down in some cases imprisoning them but mostly culturally saying you are not yet
- we will let you be a billion we will and we will let you run your
- business but when you overstep in this hybrid we're going to
- 2:43:01
- give you a a slap on the wrist or worse because you're not and there's enormous
- support in the public sector for that Americans have a very hard time grasping
- how different this is here in the United States just by
- How Elon Musk is Only an Unsuccessful Bureaucrat
- 2:43:24
- comparison the presumption is
- that government is a bureaucracy full of unnecessary people
- the fat so we economic fat
- so Mr Trump gets a lot of support
Peter Burgess COMMENTARY
Peter Burgess
Useful link:
| |